Game Preview: San Diego State Aztecs

osuHelmetOne could say that college football fans in San Diego and Columbus have had similar experiences with respect to their favorite teams. Both San Diego State and Ohio State football teams started the season with high hopes, returning teams that were the best in their respective conferences in 2012, introducing new schemes and excitement yet ultimately finding disappointment in their 2013 openers. Both teams had clearly expected that their overmatched opponents would be mere practice squads that would help in the dress rehearsal for more serious encounters to follow—starting this Saturday with each other. The differences were that Ohio State started at a much higher perceived position, suffered a much less significant game one disappointment—having to settle for a mere 20 point win over a nearly 35 point underdog Buffalo while San Diego State watched FCS Eastern Illinois reel off the last 21 points to win 40-19—and had an opening quarter of football that was as exhilaratingly successful as anyone in Columbus might have imagined.

Now both teams are looking for “rebounds” against an opponent who feels it has much to prove after its opener. One wonders then, if Ohio State does enjoy a bounce back, how impossibly high must the Aztecs improve to keep pace with the Buckeyes? That is a neat little question—on paper that is. The fact that it can be asked with such clarity is exactly why one can and should be concerned—is there a trap awaiting the Buckeyes? Is there anything we can deduce from last week’s carnage?

[Read more…]

MotSaG Look at the Offensive Tackles

osuHelmetWhat a difference a year makes — at the beginning of 2012 the big uglies portended as one of the biggest areas of concern. Now with the graduation of only right tackle Reid Fragel from a unit that became the most reliable aspect of a resurgent offensive attack, heading into 2013 the O line is projected as perhaps the most reliable unit on the team. Not that 2012 was without its difficulties. Despite a clear increase in offensive production, especially in the power run game, the sack rate stood out as a potential area of concern, though this could be laid more at the doorstep of the lingering problem that the young receiving corps had getting open in 2012.

If you focus on the trenches, you can get a good glimpse of the good and the not so good from the Michigan highlights from last year.

Starters Lost
Right tackle Reid Fragel, a converted tight end now with the Cincinnati Bengals.

2013 Outlook
Big things are expected of this group in 2013. Sports Illustrated for example has tabbed several returners for pre-season first or second B1G recognition: left tackle Jack Mewhort, left guard Andrew Norwell and center Corey Linsley. Needless to say, the blindside seems to be in good hands, but let us not skimp on the accolades here. Mewhort is proving to be a very special cat, capable of containing the most vicious of D line attackers yet capable of moving and setting up the sophisticated schemes the Buckeyes intend to run away from the trenches. And what is more, many look at his leadership potential and suggest that the most valuable role he will play is one the veteran inherits–that of team emotional soul after the departure of John Simon from last year’s edition.

Things are not exactly looking bad on the right side either. For one thing, a dominant side of the line, like the left, generally tends to also elevate the play of the other side. And the potential is there for some of the best play to come from individuals on the right side. Taylor Decker not only has won an intense battle for starting right tackle with fellow soph Chase Farris, but Decker has announced his intention to far surpass what was necessary to just win the job. With a frame one inch shorter but 15 pounds heavier than his predecessor, 6’8” monster and now Cincinnati Bengal Reid Fragel, Decker has the tools, not to mention the quickness and intelligence to make super good on that intention. And remember, Fragel rose to such heights after a late college career switch from the tight end position. Just listen to Ed Warinner about the trajectory of Decker:

It is pretty easy to understand why Urban Meyer is feeling good about his starting unit and one can start to foresee that towards the end of the year when these things could matter the most, barring injury, the offensive line, and the tackles in particular, could well evolve into the best unit in the country. Some big ifs to get through, but that vision is potentially right on the horizon.

Here is what some of the starters had to say early in camp:

The Backups
The major concern with this unit is the relative youth and inexperience of the backups. Not that they lack for talent. Sophomores Kyle Dodson and Chase Farris will challenge for backup roles at the tackle positions, as will sophomore Tommy Brown who did well in the action he saw in 2012. As the season progresses one can also expect to see highly recruited frosh Evan Lisle from Centerville emerge as a guy looking for play time at either of the tackle spots. Unfortunately incoming freshman Donovan Munger will miss the season because of a blood clot problem over the summer. Given some time it is reasonable to expect that recently converted defensive lineman Billy Price could make an impact on the offensive line though most likely at center or guard.

The Prediction
Nothing in 2013 will be as beautiful to watch as Ohio State’s big uglies.

The Best of the B1G, #1 Braxton Miller

b1g_iconThe returning B1G Offensive Player of the Year promises frightening new potential in Urban Meyer’s second year. A very early Heisman favorite, Braxton Miller will have several advantages this year that he did not have last year, including experience, continuing improved passing and a second year in Urban’s system. However, the strongest new development is the emergence of the receiving corps which for the two years prior was the Achilles heal of the offense. After the 2011 tat-gate suspensions deprived the offense of its only experienced receiver DeVier Posey, the offense has had to struggle with young receivers not yet strong enough to separate themselves with frequency.

Braxton Miller

Braxton Miller


That has all changed now. Not only does Braxton have a strong group of hardened veterans, but a strong recruiting class, highlighted by what should be the immediate impact of JUCO signee Corey Smith and playmakers Dontre Wilson, Jalin Marshall and James Clark. Also, not to be overlooked is the prospect of a healthy Jordan Hall catching passes out of the backfield alongside the power of Carlos Hyde. And we have not even gotten to tight end where Nick Vannett and Jeff Heuerman promise to be as robust as any unit. If I had to pick a surprise bust out darkhorse, I would go with junior Evan Spencer who has all the athleticism, strength and now experience to be a guy who can make a big play. But if you want to make an impact in this group, Evan you better start early.

One group that Braxton does not have to worry about is the offensive line. Replacing Reid Fragel will not be easy but there are several strong contenders and the unit, which was strong to begin with, is otherwise intact.

Funny how you can talk about Braxton’s potential and how great it looks by spending so much time on others before getting to Braxton himself. For the record, in 2012, Ohio State led the B1G in scoring offense and was third in total offense. The Buckeyes were also second in passing efficiency, rushing offense and red zone conversions. But they were eighth in passing offense, and Braxton was 7th in YPG. Braxton himself was second in overall offense and fourth in rushing but only the seventh leading passer.

The point is, Braxton has carved out his success largely by himself, that is mostly with his feet. He had no choice really, with such an inexperienced receiving corps and with banged up running backs. So the prospect of a Braxton Miller sitting in the middle of many other explosive weapons is tantalizing indeed. But from a different perspective, it was kind of like he has been strafing, with deadly precision, the B1G in a WWII Mustang fighter. Now it looks like he will be dropped in to seize the controls of a jet fighter. Perhaps that is a challenge in itself–it remains to be seen whether he can pull all the right levers with so many potential options, but given the experience he now has, one has to like his odds.

Every Reason to Smile

Every Reason to Smile

Immediately after the 2012 season ended, Braxton, got together with noted “quarterback whisperer” George Whitfield, Jr., who said , “Braxton has one of the biggest arms in college football. “I know people see his speed and his playmaking ability. But I am talking about, he’s got rare, rare arm talent.” The Spring Game obviously has been the only opportunity to view Braxton since working with Whitfield, but the results, admittedly limited, were all thumbs up. And of course, Ohio State is blessed with a very capable backup in fan favorite Kenny Guiton. So Ohio State fans can expect to buckle up and enjoy the ride–it promises to be a blast.

Previously on MotSaG’s Best of the B1G
#2 Taylor Martinez
#3 Bradley Roby
#4 Ryan Shazier
#5 Taylor Lewan
Best of the B1G, #10-6
Best of the B1G, #15-11
Best of the B1G, #20-16
Best of the B1G, #25-21

The Best of the B1G, #10 Trevor Siemian/Kain Colter

b1g_iconNorthwestern returns in 2013 with its unusually successful tandem quarterback team of redshirt junior Trevor Siemian and senior starter Kain Colter. The combination idea is not new to Northwestern who had employed it with Colter and Dan Persa. Still, the use in 2012 was initiated by Colter himself who told coach’s he was banged up so Kane Coltermuch toward the end of last year’s game at Syracuse that back-up Siemian would give the Cats the best chance to win. Siemian responded with a game winning drive. The success kept coming as Northwestern rolled to a 10-3 finish including a 34-20 New Year’s Day bowl victory over Mississippi State.

Offense was the key driver of Northwestern’s success as they finished third in the B1G in scoring offense and fifth in overall offense. And while Siemien is regarded as the better passer (finishing, as a part time player, tenth in yards per game and total yards), Colter acquitted himself nicely, actually finishing seventh passing efficiency—above Siemian. Both those statistics are driven to some extent Trevor Siemianby the fact that Siemian is the first option in obvious passing situations—so you would expect his total passing yards to get a boost while Colter’s efficiency is aided by the fact that his passing occurs when the defense is not looking pass first, but still, the Wildcats have to be pleased that either is an effective passer. If you were to combine their stats they presented a 2012 profile that was very similar to, if not slightly better than Iowa’s James Vandenberg, though each had a higher QB rating and Colter’s was actually among the best of the B1G.

Still passing needs to catch up to the Cats’ running game—which looks to be even better in 2013—if they are to improve on last year’s showing (which saw late game lasses to Penn State, Nebraska and Michigan). The schedule in 2013 includes Ohio State, Wisconsin and a trip to Cal. To make things even more difficult, Northwestern will have to replace a number of offensive linemen lost to graduation.

The intangible that makes the Northwestern quarterback duo so appealing—in addition to its relative success, is that when a team has a successful dual quarterbacking approach, it has a greater degree of insulation from severe drop-off if there is an injury. While Northwestern may have to change its game plan if there is an injury, it is only a situational adjustment, both run the read option well and both handle most aspects of the offense proficiently. If this quarterback tandem can step in up in passing proficiency—which if it happens, means the O line will have also stabilized—the Northwestern Wildcats, with upgraded facilities and a hopeful future, could become a force in the Legends division in 2013.

Previously on MotSaG’s Best of the B1G
Best of the B1G, #15-11
Best of the B1G, #20-16
Best of the B1G, #25-21

Block His Punt, But You Can’t Block JD Bergman

JD Bergman is a complex and talented man embarked on the mission of his life, which is to say his entire life. He is just the kind of person you think of when you hear the Abraham Lincoln quote which is something like: “A pessimist sees the difficulty in every opportunity; an optimist sees the opportunity in every difficulty.”

Buckeye Beginnings

While JD (twitter handle @jdbergmanusa) came to Ohio State in Fall, 2003 on a full scholarship to wrestle–a sport which he loved and at which he excelled (having won two state and three high school national titles), he really had visions of parlaying his preferred walk-on status on Jim Tressel’s football team into a becoming a starting linebacker or fullback. There was no secret about this intention: OSU wrestling coach and 1976 Olympic Silver Medalist Russ Hellickson (himself a three sport star at Wisconsin) knew of the plan and embraced it—if JD’s plan worked Russ would at least get his scholarship back and be no worse for the wear—if the plan did not work, Russ would have a wrestler on his squad who could perennially challenge for a national title.

At Oak Harbor High (a few miles southeast of Toledo), JD was the guy on the football team: running back, linebacker and punter. In fact, he was first team Ohio Div. III-IV as a running back–future OSU and NFL running back Antonio Pittman, ironically was named to the Div. III-IV second team. In the spring of his senior year, he was invited along with a few dozen players from southern Michigan and northwest Ohio to an all-star high school football banquet attended by at least 1,000 persons. Speaking extemporaneously, guest speaker Ohio State head coach Jim Tressel (twitter handle @JimTressel5), just a few months after leading his Buckeyes to a national title, specifically cited JD for his hard work on the football field and on the wrestling mat. The bond established, one thing led to another and before he knew it, JD had two opportunities at Ohio State, even if the football opportunity did not come with a scholarship attached–yet. What the relationship with Jim Tressel did for certain was that whatever doubt there might have been about his collegiate choice, JD was now going to be a Buckeye.

Life as a Gridiron Walk-on

JD did in fact start his freshman year at Ohio State as a wrestler. In fact, he had a stunning freshman year–after losing in overtime in the first round of the NCAA tourney, he won his next seven consolation bracket matches to place third in the nation–as a true freshman! Still, he stuck with his plan to pursue Ohio State football glory in the spring football season following his freshman year of wrestling. Unfortunately, after the season he participated in the freestyle wrestling US Open and injured a hand. Not being able to participate in football contact drills he hung out with the kickers, hoping to make an impression as a punter. He was befriended by then Buckeye kicker Mike Nugent and seemed to be off to a flying start.

Three events standout from JD’s brief Buckeye football career. First, at a scrimmage in Ohio Stadium, supervised by coach Tressel, JD lined up to take a long snap to punt at about his endzone in a full contact practice. The snap sailed over his head. Although he was able to get ahold of the ball before it went out of the endzone, he could not evade the 300 pound defensive linemen in ravenous pursuit and was tackled for a safety. As a walk-on JD was not coddled from facetiously loud veteran player abuse. The second event went much better—at a spring practice in front of invited Ohio high school coaches, JD bombed kicks so deep that coach Tressel told him he would be punting at the upcoming spring game.

Dream becoming reality—anyone who knows anything about Ohio State football knows how huge the spring game is. With the name “Bergman” on his back, JD ran out the tunnel for the 2004 edition with the likes of AJ Hawk, Anthony Gonzalez and Pittman. In front of a reported 45,000 screaming fans. When it came time to get on the field, JD was relieved to be kicking from mid-field, not the back of his endzone. Preparing for a high snap, JD was ready. “Hut!” The ball came low, headed for a point on the grass well in front of JD. Prepared as he was for a high snap but being shocked to see a low snap instead, JD stepped forward attempting to scoop at the same time but muffed the snap. In front of 45,000 for his only appearance in a Buckeye football game, his punt was blocked.

Sadly, or mercifully perhaps, the closest one can get to finding a record of JD’s appearance is the following from the Ohio State website “Leading the Scarlet defense was Matthews with five tackles and two sacks, while sophomore defensive back Ashton Youboty (Klein, Texas/Klein) recorded four tackles, a tackle for loss, a forced fumble, one pass breakup, a fumble recovery and a blocked punt.”

Although Coach Tressel made it clear JD could try again when healthy, knee surgeries among other injuries never permitted that to happen again. But when one door closes…

Chasing the World

Now, after a successful Ohio State wrestling career, like long-time teammate Reece Humphrey (twitter handle @reecehump60kg), JD has won two national freestyle titles sandwiched around a year of heartbreak in the 2012 Olympic qualifiers, and is poised to compete for a world title in Budapest, Hungary in September.jdbergman1

Buckeyes Humphrey and Bergman comprise two sevenths of the US World team—two others, Keith Gavin and Tervel Dlagnev train with them on the Ohio State campus at the Ohio Regional Training Center (ORTC). There are striking similarities between their Ohio State and national freestyle records (both lost NCAA titles in one point losses in the championship match). (The 2007 NCAA championships were especially eventful for JD. Wrestling in the 197 pound class, JD lost in the first round as a sixth seed. Then, starting from the very beginning of the consolation bracket, JD started an yet another epic run which like is freshman run is still talked about. Along this long and torturous route he had to beat a succession of wrestlers as they themselves dropped down from losses deeper into the championship bracket. In the consolation semifinals he beat current UFC terror “Phil Mr. Wonderful” Davis from Penn State before settling for fourth place by losing in the consolation finals to the 11th seeded Hofstra wrestler, Chris Weidman (twitter handle @ChrisWeidmanUFC), now a reigning UFC champ after his recent dramatic knockout of Anderson Silva).

Old nemesis and friend, UFC Champion Chris Weidman

Old nemesis and friend, UFC Champion Chris Weidman

Before going any further, let’s acknowledge just a few of the great coaches JD has encountered along the way, starting with youth coach and sixth grade teacher Mike Eshrich (“Mr. E”) and his dad, Jim Bergman (Ohio high school state champion from Toledo’s Cardinal Stritch–curiously, as noted in Archie Griffin Where Art Thou, Archie was a favorite by many to contend for the 1972 167 pound title–to win it, he would have had to beat actual champion Jim Bergman). He was also coached by his uncle Joe Bergman in junior high and George Bergman (longtime Oak Harbor High wrestling and football coach) in high school. He was then blessed to do his collegiate wrestling under the great Russ Hellickson mentioned above and the youthful Tom Ryan (twitter handle @buckeye158, an NCAA runner-up at Iowa where he was a teammate of the irrepressible current Iowa coach Tom Brands). He has also greatly benefited from the tutelage of Ohio State associate coach and ORTC Head Coach Lou Rosselli (@LouRosselli), who judging by the success of the ORTC, has something magical going. JD especially acknowledges the strength training he receives from JL Holdsworth and the “crossfit and crossfit mobility” training he receives from Joe Snider. (Humphrey was recruited by Hellickson and also coached by Ryan and Rosselli, and no doubt also gets an earful from old teammate, two time National Champion and current Ohio State Assistant, J. Jaggers @jjaggers2x.)

Pursuit of Personal Excellence the JD Way

JD Bergman bursts with energy in conversation, going into extraordinary depth in rapid succession on a host of different topics, but it is clear his life has evolved to one comprised of a unified collection of devotional, relationship, dietary, athletic, training, intellectual, recreational and health pursuits. He describes with charismatic evangelism the interconnectivity of the various facets that comprise his assault on life. So when you ask JD about his diet, he refuses to describe it as such—instead he refocuses the discussion on a lifestyle in which diet is but one essential part. His evangelism certainly includes that with a capital E—his Christian faith is the umbrella within which his life fits—but in toto he is an evangelist with a lower case e—all the many complex and moving parts that make up his life are to be experienced and shared with those who will receive his message, hopefully as a whole, but he is more than happy to break it down and share by component parts.

JD’s approach has evolved over time, though recently the approach has incorporated a few drastic revisions. There are several differences between the JD Bergman of last year, who lost his Olympic bid, and the JD Bergman of this year, who has emerged as a more dominant national champion than before.

JD has had his share of devastating injuries—a broken back, four knee surgeries, multiple shoulder and disc surgeries. Within the last eighteen months, he has been told that surgery is required, not merely to wrestle, but to ensure he can continue to simply walk. Indeed his wrestling, let alone wrestling at such a high level, at one point represented a clear and present danger to his health. Facing such a prognosis just when he was in a position to strive for athletic achievement on a world stage, JD has addressed it with strict faith/mind/body/care assault in an effort to change his reality.

Training

From a training regimen standpoint, JD took three months where he only stepped onto a wrestling mat a few times a week. When not wrestling during that period, he substituted cross training methods, especially borrowing from the increasingly popular crossfit and crossfit mobility regimens (crossfit mobility uses things like foam rolls and pvc pipe to do a sort of deep tissue massage). For his specific challenges, this type of cross training reduces the strain on troubled parts of his body while letting him better dictate how his training can help reduce the risk to and support the injured areas.

Diet

JD says that although blessed with youth and extraordinary athleticism, his inattention to nutrition was significantly hurting his ability to compete. He now believes, and there are persuasive voices from the scientific community in agreement, that the body was designed to run at a high level primarily using fat as a fuel source, not carbohydrates. Fat is a by-product of eating anything, whether it has nutritional value or not, that is stored until burned. Carbohydrates and their resulting sugar provide little nutritional value but are either turned to fat or burned more quickly in the expenditure of energy. Proponents believe that because of the typical American diet, most people burn sugar first and fat secondarily, thus first relying on a fuel source that introduces little nutritional value. So as a body loads up on bread, rice and pasta that convert to large amounts of sugar, the fuel source is sugar. Proponents believe a diet of mostly fruits, vegetables, fish, grassfed beef, eggs (including the yolk) and nuts, without reliance on dairy, breads and rice converts the body, especially the body of an athlete, into a machine that uses fat as its primary fuel source, which is a more powerful and efficient source of fuel. JD also insists that quality matters in the consumption of food and so he submits that food should be organic where possible and genetically modified food should be avoided.

One might think a wrestler, under constant weight loss pressure, would be burning large amounts of fat and if not losing enough to be attempting weight loss results from forskolin or other alternatives, and that’s certainly true on a relative basis. However, wrestlers pay the biggest price for weight reducing inefficiency—those who are the most inefficient wrestle at competitive disadvantage compared to the more efficient weight losing wrestler. So the margin for error is small—unnecessary pounds cannot be left on the table, so to speak. A fat burning program intuitively would seem ideal for the wrestler to the extent it is true such a program burns all available fat before sugar is added to simply fuel a training regimen.

And to JD’s mind the food dilemma involves much more. The typical American diet leads to cell inflammation which inhibits cellular waste discharge and restricts cellular nutrient intake–a double whammy. Thus the body feels unnecessary inflammatory pain (not just in muscles and joints where the pain is noticeable, but throughout the body) while starving a little at the cellular level. Again, proponents believe that the bread, rice, pasta and dairy diet leads to and exacerbates numerous health problems including diabetes, arthritis and allergies.

Strategic Use of Medical Care to Improve Quality of Life and Avoid Injury

As part of his holistic assault, JD also relies heavily and primarily on chiropractors, who he believes as a profession, are focused on and rooted more in prevention of disease. He does not quibble with the extraordinary value of modern medicine in cases of emergencies or severe damage, but so much of modern medicine is focused on addressing problems once they have occurred (after all, hospitals that need to fill beds, doctors who get paid by insurers only when patients have a clear medical need and pharmaceutical companies looking to sell drugs for actual conditions cannot really make money unless someone gets sick–prevention is bad for the provider part of the system generally). Again, these thoughts have support in the health care field at large, though reliable data is still sparse. JD’s experience is that chiropractic practitioners, who are generally cheaper and more available than doctors, have a fundamental focus on and have carved out a niche in disease prevention, and in a sense, guide their patients in more systemic ways to avoid illness and injury. He then believes the specific training they apply using mechanical methods takes stress off the nervous system and other areas of the body, including joints that are so susceptible to injury.

In practical terms, JD has combined all these elements in such dramatic fashion that surgery is no longer recommended by his physicians. Not only have his measurable conditions improved, but he is now out of substantial zones of risk. He also indicates his energy level is much better, he is far less fatigued, his workouts can now be more strenuous because his recovery time is so much shorter (in effect, naturally duplicating the effects of steroids without the harmful side effects) and he is therefore stronger and in better cardiovascular shape. His allergies have also disappeared. To a large extent we have to take JD’s word for it. However, in real terms, on the mat, anyone who saw him compete in the World Team Trials in June in Stillwater knows how dominant he has become. If you still don’t believe just watch this—->

ORTC coach Rosselli is emphatic about both JD’s dominant turnaround and the effect of JD’s programs. “There is not one formula in my experience that works, but the important thing is to have a program that works for you and that you can believe in. When JD is healthy he can beat anybody. A lot of guys don’t know what they have until it is too late. JD has grown. His nutritional plan has been exceptional and the consistency with his training has been at an elite level. He understands his body and has learned to listen to it. Sometimes we push him like we push all others but I know with JD that he is going to need to figure out what is best as he goes along–and seeing the growth he has gone through gives me confidence that I can trust him to do what is right. And he has, so sometimes when he needs a pause to do things differently, we respect that and plan accordingly. But as you saw in Stillwater, this is a guy who at age 28, in a brutally demanding sport, is on the rise and he will continue to get better if he sticks with what he has learned.”

The results are apparent to us. The reasons are clear to JD.

A Man on a Mission

Spirituality plays a large role: one can readily understand the clarity JD insists he achieves through devotion: whether before a match for concentration on the specifics of the task at hand or as a resort to a source of strength; or in training as a means of breaking down his sport in ways he can understand to better attack his own areas of weakness. One can also understand how thoughtful attention to a code of conduct can simplify choices and remove the tugs of self doubt or uncertainty as one decides how to deal with those choices. But to JD it is more. God has given him a body that is intended to be fed and cared for in a certain way—it is his job, in commanding the machine God has blessed him with, to operate it effectively and efficiently.JDbergman3
Thus, in this context, what seem to be setbacks, especially when viewed from the narrow perspective of pursuing an Olympic title, actually become opportunities when viewed in light of the broader goal. So it is that, rather than complain about time lost to injury, JD approaches the time off as a blessing because it affords the opportunity to be involved with youth projects and share on several levels, including spiritually.

Likewise, while losses on the mat are not a frequent occurrence, to JD they have to be put in perspective. Woody Hayes once said, “show me a gracious loser and I’ll show you a bus boy.” JD has his own perspective: “People often don’t understand losses. Don’t get me wrong, I really hate to lose and think only about how I win every match, and I drive through each match so that if I am in danger of losing by one point, I win by one–it takes a mindset. But it is important how you handle a loss when it happens and put it in perspective regarding how you are growing. Win or lose you can learn and keep getting better. But if you lose and think that just because you lost you’ve regressed, guess what? You just really did regress. Fear of losing becomes a big liability for a lot of people and it retards their growth and artificially lowers their ceiling.”

For much of what you might expect an athlete to do in retirement, you see JD doing now. Public speaking, whether through wrestling camps or as an invited speaker in a variety of settings—church, sport, alumni, promotional, civic—is a cherished opportunity to share his approach to life. If JD were to settle on a specific non-wrestling goal right now he does not jest when he insists it would be to host a food or nutrition show that meets his evangelical approach to eating and living. It is no surprise that JD has found himself in front of a camera—when the eagerly awaited Channing Tatum, Mark Ruffalo and Steve Carell wrestling movie “Foxcatcher” comes out about the time this fall that JD is involved in his world title quest—he can be seen in the movie. He and Humphrey can also be seen with Buckeye Tommy Rowlands (twitter handle @Tommy Rowlands) in the Ithaka Project, a moving documentary on wrestling (see twitter @IthakaFilm2012). But first things first. JD was selected to film a potentially lucrative Nike commercial—an opportunity he had to turn down because the filming coincided with his date in Stillwater, Oklahoma last month for the World Team Trials.jdbergman2

JD also is a huge ambassador, inside and outside of his sport. For years he has served on USA Wrestling Committees, serving as a voice for the safety and concern of the athletes. An enthusiastic and engaged communicator, he takes on several causes simultaneously—again, as part of his interconnected approach to life. Emblematic is a t-shirt JD produced calling attention to wrestling’s fight to stay in the Olympics, his own pursuit of Olympic gold and his deep faith, emblazoned with “respect all, fear ONE.”

Wrestling is, as almost everyone knows, the oldest original Olympic sport, and is in an uphill fight (a fight that seems increasingly winnable) to stave off Olympic ostracization. While wrestling is in fact one of the most popular sports in the world—170 countries wrestle at the Olympic level—it is a sport that perhaps because of its ancient roots and because of where it is most popular (Russia, Iran, Bulgaria, to name a few)—has resisted change. It is ironic that the potential Olympic abolition of the most ancient Olympic sport is in many respects attributable to holding itself hostage to ancient precepts. The move to more actively involve athletes in wrestling’s administration, the scoring rule changes to make the sport more understandable and exciting for the fans, and the expansion to include female wrestling are breathtakingly beautiful changes that were long overdue.

JD thus believes that while dropping wrestling from the Olympics would be “ridiculously stupid, the changes that are resulting by the threat are some of the best things that could have happened.” In September, the International Olympic Committee will finally decide wrestling’s fate. In September, JD will chase the dream of becoming world champion. Almost simultaneously, JD and his sport will look to overcome adversity and become all the richer because of it.

Archie Where Art Thou?

dispatch_wrestling_1972

What, or rather, who is missing from this picture? A very intense Ohio State fan could tell you about one person who is in this picture—one of the Central Ohio District Champions pictured above, Pat Curto, went on to gridiron fame as a defensive end on some of Woody’s best teams of the mid 70s. And local wrestling enthusiasts will recognize young sensation Mike Chinn who would go on to be a collegiate wrestling All-American at Louisiana State where he would place fifth in the 1978 NCAAs.

But still the remarkable thing about this picture is who is missing—Archie Griffin. Not many of his adoring fans know that both Archie and his younger brother Ray were also sensational wrestlers at Eastmoor High in Columbus. One lucky soul recounted how he watched Woody Hayes quietly sneak into the side door of Upper Arlington’s gym during the 1973 District Championships just to peak around the side bleachers for brief glimpses of Ray competing in that year’s championships.

As for Archie, legend has it that at some point in his high school wrestling career, he commanded a 24-1 record in the 167 pound weight class—his only loss being by disqualification from a body slam perpetrated on an overmatched opponent. Indeed, the week before at the sectional qualifying tournament at Brookhaven, Archie worked his way through the championship by pinning advancing wrestlers from Walnut Ridge, Brookhaven and Gahanna in 54 second, 43 seconds and one minute six seconds. In the finals he demolished Dave Wickline of Reynoldsburg. Few apparently doubted Archie would win the district title and then advance to the state tournament where he would have been a heavy favorite to join Curto as one of two “big school” state champions from Central Ohio that year (Central Ohio, led by Bob Triano’s DeSales Stallions, always performed with distinction in the small school division at the time).

Years later, I had a surprise opportunity to be part of a small group luncheon with Archie in San Diego. Although I really don’t remember the purpose, I am sure it related to Archie’s outreach role with Ohio State—presumably for fundraising. I had heard a few things about that weekend in 1972, mainly that Archie had lost 11-1 in overtime Whetstone’s Pat Dickerson—who indeed is seated in the picture above and identified as a district runner-up, also headed to the state meet the next week. This would have been no ordinary loss—having won one match already at the district tournament, the winner would go to the district finals that evening and would fill one of the two spots in the state tournament the following week—the loser’s season would have been finished. I had also heard that Archie had wrestled Dickerson twice before, including during the Columbus City League Championships and that he had absolutely overpowered Dickerson both times, as Archie had done to all his opponents (don’t feel sorry for the young Dickerson—by all accounts, he and Wickline were both highly accomplished and successful wrestlers—the point being, Archie Griffin was a force unto himself).

Now here I am sitting with one of my favorite Buckeyes and one of the most iconic persons in all of sport—the only two-time Heisman winner to date, hero of so many great Buckeye teams and mentor, confidante and friend to all in the Buckeye community. It never occurred to me that a man who had achieved such heights, who had accumulated so many friends and admirers and who had so much to occupy his busy life would care much or even recall much about an athletic moment so obscure and so unrelated to his future achievements.

So I asked, him—how in the world was it that he could lose such an important match to a person he had twice clobbered—and how did he get to overtime just to lose in such dominating fashion?
Wow. Nothing prepared me for the reaction I received. There might have been some resentment to the way in which I asked the question, which was intended as a warm and humorous inquiry into a sidebar in the life of someone who had accomplished so much, but which might have come off as glib and cutting. But the scene could not have been more dramatic in my mind if the windows had been blown open by hurricane winds and Archie had been transformed from this jovial, warm ambassador of all things Ohio State to one of the ring wraiths who had just encountered Frodo Baggins. I’m sure I was too stunned by this sudden change in demeanor to remember what he really said, but to me it sounded like, “you silly poor excuse of a wretched measly little subterranean troll—I HAD THE FLU!!!!”

The flu—what a moron I had been to not even think of such a possibility.

Ok, so the mystery was solved, but the stark change in friendliness (which may have only been a figment of my imagination as I tried to cope with his surprisingly visceral reaction), demeanor, fire with which he recounted the details of the match and the obvious pain he revealed in describing what to many might have seemed just a mild bump on the road to greatness left a deep impression on me, not just with regard to him, but as to sport in general and wrestling in particular.

I did not hold it against Archie that he became dark over that moment. If there was any personal embarrassment, it was mine. Perhaps I asked the question inartfully, perhaps this was not the forum to ask such a question. But to see, years later, how personal this failure to achieve was, even when not his fault and after he had accomplished so much and had attained so much love and recognition, gave me a direct insight as to just how driven this man was and obviously remains as an athlete and a person.

This incident raised my already healthy respect for Archie in a way that took me years to digest. True, it was direct evidence of the drive so often associated with highly successful athletes. It is interesting to see that in person, but it is not really anything novel or rarely witnessed or remarked upon. Archie’s talents on the football field were undoubtedly attributable to a strong work ethic, but much was also attributable to gifts that essentially are God given such as raw speed and the innate ability to see a hole and have the quickness to race through it.

But wrestling is different. God given talent still counts for a lot, but individuals with lesser amounts can still excel through extraordinary fitness, strength training, attention to technique, practice and most importantly an attitude of physically and personally dominating another athlete who is trying to do the same to you.

Archie did not just excel in wrestling—he obliterated his competition in a fashion that actually exceeded his domination on the football field. And wrestling is not detached by the isolation of a helmet, the open field or the shared and thus somewhat de-individualized joint experience with teammates—it is mano y mano, you against me and if you cannot smash me I will do just that to you, up close and personal, looking into your very eyes while twisting and throwing your body around at my will. Wrestling is an intensely intellectual endeavor—one in which every move has a counter, and every counter has a counter. It is also a very tedious study in hundreds of discreet body movements that have to be practiced over and over again so that they can be called on for use without thought in moments of intense physical stress. It is competition at its most basic and most personal level.

Archie’s obvious pain years after his high school disappointment, to me at least, said that having done everything possible to reach a goal in such a personal arena, only to have it yanked away because he might have had the unfortunate luck to suck on the same contaminated orange juice bottle being passed around in practice the week before, was to cheat him out of something that he had earned through unrelenting devotion to extremely hard, intellectual and tedious work, not merely something that he could achieve because of other gifts given him or shared with others. It was like “I busted my ass for years, learned everything there was to learn, lifted other strong men high into the air against their will and threw them onto their backs. I did all that by myself, I had reached the top and for no fault of my own, when the prize for all that effort was there for me, I had at snatched and given to an opponent who had not gone through nearly the hell I had—this is so unfair!”

And from Archie’s perspective there was another reason why wrestling might have meant so much for him. Consider Pat Curto, who as noted was a state champion that year. Pat was a key member of the defensive front on those great Buckeye teams. As a big defensive end he got his fill of combat and clamping down on running backs, quarterbacks and others. To a guy like him, wrestling was probably an awful lot like play on a defensive line. But to a speedster like Archie, his job on the football field was to avoid the punishment guys like Curto dealt out. Archie could certainly deliver a hit himself, but it was generally his job to avoid and actually run away from the imposing monsters on the other side. But in wrestling, Archie was the monster, he was the aggressor, he was the man with the ability to throw another talented athlete to the ground and make him submit. That form of combat had to appeal to Archie as a form of personal vindication and retribution for what he faced on the football field and of course he would have mourned the opportunity for the world at large to take notice of how he handled himself in the field of combat.

Those are the type of things I think Archie was screaming about from the inside. I don’t really think he was angry at me, and as awkwardly as I may or may not have raised the issue, I do not think he resented my bringing it up.

Sadly, that was the last the world would see of Archie on the wrestling mat—Woody would not allow his football players to wrestle—in an era when dual sports were more doable. What a shame that was because when you just consider the benefit to an otherwise serviceable wrestling program guys like Curto, Ray and Archie could have provided, Ohio State was hiding a good part of its wrestling lamp in an era in which it could have enjoyed great success. The rich, though obscure to most, history of Ohio State wrestling that has included the iconic names of Humphrey, Randleman, Rowlands, Bergman, Jaggers and Stieber, incredibly, could have had a very bright light shined on it if had been allowed to include the name of one Archie Griffin. But there were Rose Bowls to play in, national titles to contend for and Heismans to be won and cherished. The small but real opportunity that a wrestling injury could have done is admittedly too heavy a consideration to dismiss, so at a personal level, what happened to Archie in high school took from him the last and best validation of service well performed in an endeavor he so obviously cherished.

I have not talked to Archie since and it is doubtful he knows of my existence and unlikely he remembers that conversation in San Diego. Perhaps he would disagree with my resolution of this episode in his life, but I bet at some basic level he would not. I should probably ask him, but the idealist within me prefers to think of it this way. Luck and happenstance treated me to a front seat at a window on greatness and gave me a deeply personal reason to cherish someone who had been previously just an idol from a distance but more importantly helped me better understand the unique place an ancient and unique sport enjoys, even among the most cherished and accomplished of our heroes.

What I should have asked Archie, and what I would in fact ask given the chance to do it all over, was, “to what extent did the hard work in the wrestling room benefit you on the gridiron”? In a parallel universe I am enjoying the warm glow that would have followed had I just done that.

Reece Humphrey: A Buckeye Family on the World Stage

ReeceHump2

“Don’t judge me” defiant Parker Humphrey declares from his twitter account, @parkerhump14kg. At two years old, Parker may be thought by many to be too young to be an active tweeter, but defying convention has become a time honored Humphrey tradition. Indeed, with his healthily distended little belly he is right to contest the scorn of those who might disapprove of his dual fisted attack on two ice cream cones at once. The literal translation of Parker’s protest might in fact be a warning, “Dad, you do things your way, I’ll do mine my way!”ParkerHump

A fitting admonition indeed to a man wending his way through the madness of life at the top of the world’s most demanding sport, wrestling. The last vision of Reece Humphrey in competition was the backflip completion of an effortless double flip immediately after winning his second US National Title in Stillwater Oklahoma, in June 2013. In fact, little has been conventional about Humphrey’s journey to the top but no wrestler goes about his business with more genuine youthful exuberance than Buckeye Nation’s own Mr. Humphrey.

Parker’s granddad, Buckeye Jim Humphrey from Coshocton, Ohio, was himself a remarkably talented wrestler, having been a five time national freestyle champion, world silver medalist and Olympic alternate (unfortunately that was the 1980 Olympic team—which was denied the opportunity to compete in Moscow as part of President Carter’s boycott because of Soviet interference in Afghanistan).

Grandad Buckeye Jim Humprhey, From the '70s

Grandad Buckeye Jim Humprhey, From the ’70s

Although it would be natural to think Jim would have tutored Reece in wrestling from a very early age, Reece declares he had no inkling of his father’s success until after he took up wrestling himself. Reece got into wrestling in the sixth grade, which is quite late for a guy who has enjoyed the exalted view from where Reece has, and then only because his older brother Jordin stumbled into it. Reece recalls being at an instructional camp and seeing his dad show up to help teach and can be excused for thinking, as he did, “what the heck is he doing, he doesn’t know anything about wrestling.” Looking at Jim’s old photos from the early 70s Reece might have confused his dad with singers Jim Croce or Cat Stevens more than Dan Gable–busting out with “Time In a Bottle” must have seemed far more appropriate to Reece than his dad walking through the mechanics a high crotch takedown.

In some respects, Reece’s very success seems unconventional in the eyes of national writers and fans, who somehow incomprehensively seem almost surprised to find him at the top of a podium. The public mindset often establishes a peculiarized test of legitimacy that in wrestling is often based on NCAA titles—much like the basketball world tests its superstars on the basis of NBA titles won. Reece, like his father before him, had a great career at Ohio State but also like his father never won an NCAA title, though each acquitted himself with very high distinction. In 2009 Reece finished second at 133, losing a close 6-5 match to heated rival Franklin Gomez of Michigan State and in 2010, he finished third at 141 after having had the misfortune to meet freshman Kyle Dake in the semifinals as Dake was at the beginning of his historic run to four NCAA titles in four different weight classes.

So it was a surprise and indeed an upset to many when Reece defeated all comers, of any age, to become the 2011 national champion and world team representative (after placing fourth in the 2010 NCAA 141 pound weight class, Reece dropped to the 60 kilo weight class in 2011, which is 132 pounds). After his unfortunate loss in the 2012 Olympic trials, the temptation was to label the 2011 win an aberration. (In truth the only “fluke” was the bizarre match scoring and overtime rules then in existence which in the event of any tied two minute period, resorted to a purely random “ball drop” to start the ball drop winner in a superior position that resulted in a sudden victory “win” 90 percent of the time. Reece was twice victimized by that rule in a 2012 wrestle-off with former Oklahoma State Cowboy Coleman Scott who parlayed his two out of three period win against Reece into a face-off where he beat Shawn Bunch for the 60 kilo US Olympic spot. Disregarding the randomness of the ball drop the only person to actually win a period by conventional means in the Scott/Humphrey match—indeed the only person to score an actual point in the match—was Reece Humphrey). The 2013 win, now his second in three years, should now remove whatever doubts might have lingered as to Reece’s legitimacy as champion of the 60 kilo weight class.

But Reece Humphrey, now 26, is chasing an Olympic and world title and as such is again an underdog. His showings on the world stage have not been overpowering to date and he recently lost in disappointing fashion to his Iranian counterpart in the “Rumble on the Rails” at Grand Central Station in New York (also under the old rules). Nonetheless, a ninth place finish in Turkey (where the ball drop was yet again a factor in a quarterfinal loss to Didier Pais of France) in 2011 is no small achievement, and one could note that Scott, the 2012 Olympic qualifier who went on to finish second to Humphrey in the 2013 US Open, earned a bronze medal in 2012. A world title is well within Humphrey’s reach.

Reece believes his body is up to the challenge, which now must span three years if it is to culminate in a spot on the Olympic team in Brazil in 2016. He believes he has learned to train smarter and to avoid injury. And he believes he has gotten much better at managing his weight in a consistent manner that will leave him better prepared at match time. Indeed, for dietary and to some extent training matters, he borrows select pages from the all-out assault on life practiced by long-time friend and teammate JD Bergman. JD’s “diet”, which JD does not describe as such—instead calling it part of an overall change in lifestyle—eschews most grains, breads, sugars, processed foods and seeks out as much raw and organic food as possible—one goal being to burn body fat not merely sugar.

One also suspects that if he is to achieve success on a world stage, Reece will in fact continue along his own unconventional past. Reece Humphrey is a remarkably aware and thoughtful person. As an illuminating example, when asked what he might do after wrestling, he rotely goes through a laundry list that includes coaching, establishing a career sustaining wrestling club and sales positions within the sports and wrestling business. When specifically asked he admits to how much he would love to get involved in MMA fighting, but quickly dismisses it out of family objection. But the prospect that really lights him up is the intellectual tight rope world of high stakes professional poker!

So there is a familiar arc of success at work that has guided him from latecomer to twice national champion and seems at work again as he plots out his final three years in the arena, and perhaps beyond—the proven ability to out-think the rest of the world. “Yes, I had a successful wrestling father who is a big reason for my success—but that did not help me get started earlier and in fact I started very late, so to a big extent that was not an advantage, and beside lots of wrestlers have knowledgeable fathers who helped them along the way. And yes, I work hard, but really it is pretty difficult to outwork the best—we are all working very hard. What I have always done is to focus as much as I can on what I have done, what works and what has not worked, what works for someone else and how he can be attacked. The mental aspect of wrestling is how I have tried to differentiate myself and has been really what has helped me make up any gap I have ever felt.”

Wrestlers are commonly thought to be brutes, and the mere connotation of brutishness de-emphasizes the possibility that extreme mental acuity is required. But much like offensive linemen, the truth is that few endeavors require so much mental ability and quickness—and under extreme and violent circumstances. For every move there is a counter, for every counter there is a counter and at the highest level it is the mind that can think ahead and execute most crisply and decisively that prevails. Wrestling can be compared to trying to do a Rubic’s cube while being jostled in traffic—figure it out fast or get run over.

Any time he has faced a roadblock, Reece has fallen back on intensive study and devotion to understand what it takes at a very precise level to move past the roadblock. That formula has worked extremely well in the past and shows every sign that it continues to lead the way to success.
But Reece’s personal arc of success contains another critical constant. Reece had the fortune of having a mentor in his father who was wise enough to let Reece discover his own passion and gave Reece the space to figure out how to move that passion forward in a way that worked for Reece. While Reece may have come to wrestling late, he came to it honestly as it became his dream first, not his father’s. And then he had the benefit of a father who never pushed him to the point of burning out. Now, as an adult, his principal life relationship is with wife Meredith, also a Buckeye. If you ask Reece what is unique about him that you cannot read somewhere, he answers simply, “Meredith.”

Meredith Humphrey

Meredith Humphrey

This of course resembles a cliché, except that as you put it all together, you realize how truly significant and apt it is in the specific case of Reece Humphrey. Meredith, perhaps without intending to, seems to push buttons in the precisely same correct and supportive way as father Jim once did. Dreams of achievement are funny things—they can choke people and strain relationships and they can devastate people if not achieved. People handle them in different ways, achieve them in different ways, fail to achieve them in different ways and deal with the consequences of success or failure in different ways. Somehow the consistent theme of those principally involved in the intersection of their lives and Reece’s athletic chase has been how they have complemented him and nurtured him; how all involved have put those important yet personal and unpredictable dreams in context as still smaller than a life being lived and still smaller than a relationship among loved ones; and how all have still given honor to the dreams of just the one of them and given those dreams the necessary devotion or space as and when needed. It is an intricate and delicate equation that most don’t fully solve over time, especially given the youthful and fragile stage at which athletic dreams generally must be fulfilled. And because it is a process that does in fact arc over a good portion of life and responsibility gets shifted from person to person, like father to wife, it is a process that is so prone to breaking down.

So when Reece Humphrey says he owes everything right now to his wife, he is not speaking in cliché, but rather what he is saying, from the heart, is that father, son, wife and all have gotten through the most demanding transitions of this phase of a life with big and immensely hard dreams. As he was once in the hands of a wise and respectful mentor, he is now in the embrace of a wise and respectful partner, and as to their parts, father and wife have achieved a flawless passing of the baton. Of course dad is still involved—he was in Reece’s corner in the conclusive match in Stillwater, insisting on a video review for which Reece had no patience (he was still ahead and in typical youthful fashion, just wanted to get on with things) and the review resulted in a technical fall (win by seven points or more) to end the match right there in Reece’s favor. The point is, Meredith has taken over as life partner and dad has given up that role to remain as coach—an amazingly hard transition in the most average of circumstances and yet it has taken place successfully while witnessing the highest level of athletic achievement.

Go Bucks

Go Bucks

We can all be confident, that as the times arise, young Parker is not in fact judged but instead is and will be given the opportunity to choose his dreams and the support to fulfill them—because that is the unconventional Humphrey way.

The View from Rutgers: Conference Re-Alignment, UFC, Recruiting and Other Matters of Amateur Athletics

b1g_icon“The campus is alive—people can tell you much more about the 2014 football schedule than they can about the 2013 schedule” says Scott Goodale, coach of the Rutgers wrestling team. Starting fall, 2014, the Scarlet Knights will begin competition in the Big Ten which will then expand to 14 members with the addition of Rutgers and ACC charter member Maryland. For the record, in 2014, Rutgers football will receive visits from Michigan, Penn State and Wisconsin and will go on the road to play Ohio State, Nebraska and Maryland (by contrast, in 2013, the last season before Big Ten play, the Scarlett Knights play the likes of Arkansas, Houston, Louisville, Cincinnati,  Connecticut, Central Florida and South Florida).  The renewal of their long-time rivalry with Penn State has to be particularly exciting given that the two programs have not played since 1995—shortly after Penn State ceased being an independent power by joining the Big Ten.

While some treat this affiliation as a big yawn, one only has to dig a little deeper to appreciate why this could well be a move where the sum is much more significant than its parts.  I had a chance to sit down with Coach Goodale, who happened to be in my adopted home, Carlsbad, CA on a recruiting visit.  I was struck by how a wrestling program at a school like Rutgers now sits right in the middle of some of the big amateur sports and Olympic issues of our day.

Rutgers has certainly enjoyed football success, and much of it in the last decade, but few would pretend it has cracked into the level of consistently being an elite program, despite being a major football playing power in the talent rich Atlantic seaboard region.  While one always has to be careful about comparing football, which is species unto itself, to other athletics programs, in this instance Rutgers wrestling may be a useful comparator as it also sits in a talent rich region.

“The problem we have is that if a wrestler is interested in us, he is probably also interested and capable of getting into Princeton, Harvard, etc., so we often lose that wrestler. If he is capable of wrestling at a higher level, he often chooses the Big Ten, so we are somewhat caught in the middle.”  One suspects football is much the same—the Big East is typically not the recruiting draw that other conferences are for top tier talent, and while Rutgers may not have to compete with the Ivies for the next level of high school football talent, they still have to share that talent with a number of competing programs such as Boston College, West Virginia, Connecticut, Temple to name just a few.

Thus, at least for football, wrestling and many other sports, one suspects, the move to the Big Ten has to be seen as a recruiting bonanza, a point directly underscored by Coach Goodale.  There are some exceptions—while Rutgers may in fact be able to amp up the basketball excitement for moving to the Big Ten, the Big East was of course among the elite of basketball conferences (underscore “was” as the Catholic seven bolt from the rest of the old Big East—even retaining the name). Some sports might actually have a tougher go—men’s soccer for example where four current Big Ten teams do not sponsor a team (Nebraska, Iowa, Minnesota and Purdue).  Despite the overall prestige of the Big Ten, it might be tougher to recruit soccer players into a conference where less than all members are enthusiastic—one can only imagine how men’s lacrosse recruits in lacrosse-mad Maryland view the move to the much less lacrosse serious Big Ten (though the addition of powerhouse Johns Hopkins as a Big Ten lacrosse member does provide a powerful counter for that particular concern).

Obviously of course, the new money that will funnel through to Rutgers because of the move to the Big Ten will be felt across the board as the annual take, while uncertain at this point, will be millions more than it enjoyed before the move.  While football recruiting will not be affected at least in terms of scholarships, facilities will doubtlessly improve and recruiting in other sports will improve.  Wrestling was already fully funded in that the full NCAA allotment of 9.9 annual scholarships is provided at Rutgers—however, the dollar amount is based on in-state tuition, meaning it is quite a bit tougher to recruit out of state kids who typically have to pay a portion of tuition at out of state rates.  The increased budget as a result of joining the Big Ten is likely to allow filling those scholarships with out of state rates—a significant new bonus for the non-revenue sports.

Indeed, for 2014, the first recruiting year in which the jump to the Big Ten has had an effect as a recruiting tool, Rutgers has seen an impressive bump in the rankings of its commitments, highlighted so far by the overall number 60 ranked high school wrestler, Anthony Giraldo, ironically from nearby North Bergen NJ.  “Last year I would have been basically limited to driving around New Jersey looking for athletes. This year I am talking to you in Southern California as I recruit the best kids in the country—kids that know that by the time they arrive on campus they will have the chance to compete for a Big Ten title,”  says Coach Goodale.  With no disrespect whatsoever to the proud and successful Eastern Intercollegiate Wrestling Association, where Rutgers participates through the 2013-14 season, it is quite a step up to be able to tell recruits they will compete for their entire careers in the Big Ten—a conference that produced six of ten 2013 NCAA champions.

Football recruiting seems to be off to a similarly stalwart start.  College football recruiting rankings, inherently suspect, are even more specious when it comes to mid-year snapshots.  Nonetheless, after finishing 45th in the Yahoo/Rivals 2013 rankings, Rutgers football is up to 16th in the latest 2014 rankings (as of now, Maryland has not enjoyed a similar bump).

One also suspects this change in the state of Rutgers recruiting reflects an expanded travel budget in anticipation of Big Ten riches as much as it does the prospect of offering recruits the opportunity to wrestle in the dominant wrestling conference in the country once they arrive.

I was surprised to learn from Coach Goodale that the there is not a lot of buzz within the college wrestling community about the Ed O’Bannon case and its impact on collegiate sports.  It might be that wrestling is fighting too many other battles right now to worry about the speculative effect of what that case might bring.  Wrestling, which has been devastated perhaps as much as any sport because of Title IX, now worries about how the impact of a potential loss of wrestling in the Olympics might further erode its brand appeal with young athletes.  Since February when the Olympic executive board recommended dropping wrestling after the 2016 Olympics, many feel the battle being waged for permanent Olympic reinstatement September is being won.

It is ironic that one of the adjustments made by US and International wrestling to save wrestling in the Olympics has been to further embrace women’s wrestling.  One wonders, as Title IX continues to chip away at wrestling (for example, proponents were saddened to learn of Boston University’s recent decision to drop wrestling), could women’s wrestling not only help on the Olympic level but on the collegiate level as well? Wrestling is not a capital intensive sport—if a college can adopt a women’s program, the same facilities could of course support a men’s team.  And if the O’Bannon case does shrink the dollars available for non-revenue sports, could a sport like wrestling address Title IX and still restrain costs in a post-O’Bannon era? While women’s wrestling is still not on the shortlist yet of programs to be added by major universities, the list of smaller colleges adopting wrestling programs is impressive and growing.  Coach Goodale could not speculate on the future of women’s wrestling except to indicate there is a palpable buzz that did not exist in prior years and added: “if you watch women wrestlers at the highest level, it is really impressive how far they have come in just a few short years.  If this catches on, I could see women’s wrestling becoming a major force.”

Among the changes that wrestling adopted to save its Olympic cache was a revamp of bizarre and almost random scoring rules.  The most hated was a “ball drop” to decide a tie where one wrestler was awarded a starting position that led to a win nearly 90% of the time.  For the most part, fans and wrestlers have applauded the move to the new rules which penalize passivity and end a lopsided match more quickly.  Coach Goodale thought some of the new freestyle rules could have a beneficial effect at the collegiate level, especially the passivity rule which, if there has been no score for a set period, the referee declares one wrestler as the passive wrestler.  If no one scores in the next 30 seconds, the non-passive wrestler is awarded a point.  “I also like the one point awarded on a push out—make them wrestle in the middle.” Continuing, Coach Goodale adds, “and recently, someone suggested awarding three points for just the first takedown—that might make things more exciting too if a premium was put on early aggression.”

Despite potential challenges on the horizon for wrestling, in some respects the future of wrestling has never been brighter.  As the key building block for the immensely popular MMA/UFC, wrestling has an opportunity to reach a young, excited and huge audience–a genuine opportunity for mass appeal. Former Buckeye wrestling star Tommy Rowlands has been one of the most active persons in linking the popular consciousness of MMA to its wrestling roots.  Some of the most dominant fight names are and have been collegiate wrestlers, including Brock Lesnar, Randy Couture, Chuck Liddell, Chael Sonnen, Phil, “Mr. Wonderful” Davis and Buckeye strongman and pioneer Kevin Randleman.  Wrestlers watched former Hofstra star Chris Weidman rock the world by ending the seven year reign of former middleweight champion Anderson Silva.  The night was particularly sweet for the Rutgers wrestling community, Coach Goodale and his close friend,  volunteer Rutgers coach Frankie Edgar, former featherweight champ (currently ranked No. 3).  Edgar, one of the most popular UFC fighters of his era, shared the card with New Yorker Weidman and won an exciting and decisive bout against physically imposing up and coming Charles Oliveira.  Wrestlers now have exciting options beyond coaching—and the potential to earn enormous income.  “You see a great guy like Frankie Edgar, how much he means to the UFC and how much wrestling has meant to him.  He works out with our team as one of the guys–it is exciting to the kids, but you can tell Frankie gets a lot out of it too in terms of his own fight preparation.  I would never want to get hit in the face, but these guys come out of college, and they are so tough, and they have mastered the art of close contact and precise maneuvers.  For most of them, picking up boxing and cementing the other pieces is actually pretty easy given what they have already mastered, and before long, they are the ones dishing out the punishment. This fight game has gone way past boxing, and it is exciting that our young men are so much a part of it” observes Coach Goodale.  Then, siting back with eyes on the horizon, he added, “and hey, young women too. It’s an exciting new time, and I’m glad I’m a part of it.”

Indeed it is.  Welcome Scarlet Knights.