Breaking: NCAA to punish next year’s seniors with 2012 Bowl Ban
In true Columbus Disptach fashion, they have ignored the requested news embargo and prempted everyone’s coverage of the upcoming report from the NCAA. The news is bad. All around bad:
The NCAA today stunned Ohio State University’s football program by banning it from postseason play after the 2012 season, multiple sources told The Dispatch.
The penalty means Ohio State automatically is out of the running for any bowl, or a Big Ten or national championship next year, just as newly appointed head coach Urban Meyer is wooing recruits to the Buckeyes.
Athletic Director Gene Smith said previously that while Ohio State has been declared a repeat violator that failed to properly monitor its football program, a bowl ban would be out of line with penalties handed to universities with similar violations.
There will be time to opine on the nuances at a later time, but for now we’ll just say that this sucks. Punishing the upcoming seniors like Jake Stoneburner, John Simon and others really stings.
What’s your initial take?
South Carolina In Game Chat
We don’t do these for every game but it’s Saturday and we’ve go to do SOMETHING before the bowl games. Join us for a live chat during the OSU Men’s Basketball game against the South Carolina Gamecocks:
Buckeyes curbstomp Duke Blue Devils 85-63
Here, in numerical order, is a list of teams that give me the most satisfaction when My Team beats them:
1. Michigan (Football) – always and forever
2. Michigan (Basketball)
3. Duke
4. Pittsburgh Steelers
5. L.A. Lakers
Also, Coach K is no doubt going to regret his final quote in the above linked ESPN story:
“I’ve had my butt kicked before,” Krzyzewski said. “We’ve kicked some butt. Tonight my butt’s sore.”
BlogPoll Ballot Week 14
With all the excitement of yesterday, I decided to hold of a day on our BlogPoll Ballot.
This week, our ballot is brought to you by SYR:
Men of the Scarlet and Gray Ballot – Week 14
| Rank | Team | Delta |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | LSU Tigers | — |
| 2 | Oklahoma St. Cowboys | — |
| 3 | Alabama Crimson Tide | — |
| 4 | Boise St. Broncos | — |
| 5 | Stanford Cardinal | — |
| 6 | Virginia Tech Hokies | — |
| 7 | Houston Cougars | — |
| 8 | USC Trojans | — |
| 9 | Oregon Ducks | — |
| 10 | Arkansas Razorbacks | — |
| 11 | Oklahoma Sooners | — |
| 12 | Michigan St. Spartans | — |
| 13 | Wisconsin Badgers | — |
| 14 | Georgia Bulldogs | — |
| 15 | Kansas St. Wildcats | — |
| 16 | Michigan Wolverines | — |
| 17 | South Carolina Gamecocks | — |
| 18 | TCU Horned Frogs | — |
| 19 | Southern Miss. Golden Eagles | — |
| 20 | Baylor Bears | — |
| 21 | Nebraska Cornhuskers | — |
| 22 | Penn St. Nittany Lions | — |
| 23 | Clemson Tigers | — |
| 24 | West Virginia Mountaineers | — |
| 25 | Notre Dame Fighting Irish | — |
SB Nation BlogPoll College Football Top 25 Rankings »
Live Blogging Ohio State Press Conference
(Available on pretty much any local Columbus News Channel, Ohio State Buckeyes dot com and at BT2Go)
5:15 (Gene Smith at the podium) “Our next head football coach, Mr. Urban Meyer” – pretty much the greatest thing Gene Smith has ever said.
5:17 “One of the premier leaders in football”
5:19 “This is the right time for Urban Meyer to lead our football program”
“Let me take this opportunity to thank Luke Fickell… He was the right leader for this program at that time.”
5:20 “Coach Fickell will be our coach for the Bowl Game”
5:23 (Urban Meyer at the podium) “I’m deeply honored to … lead the Ohio State program.”
“If it was but for the coaching position at the Ohio State University, I would not have coached this year (this coming year).”
5:25 “Our goal is to compete and win Big Ten Championships”
“It’s good to be home.”
5:26 “The interest in this program is overwhelming.”
“Health-wise, I feel great … I feel fantastic now.”
5:30 “If you’re the best offensive line coach, I want you here.” (Sorry, Coach Bollman)
5:32 “I did a lot of research” (He’s said that quite a few times. I like that)
5:33 Meeting Braxton Miller was Coach Meyer’s “highlight of the day”. “real excited” (We’re all excited, Urban)
5:36 “Go hard”
5:38 “We need an EMS to the back please.” (Camera shaking and awkward rubber-necking)
5:41 “I understand the significance of that game” (referring to the OSU/Michigan game)
“The one thing I know about that game, there is a lot of respect in that rivalry”
5:43 “I’m putting a lot of pressure on this kid (Miller) already.”
5:46 Speaking of discipline: “If we have one (incident) we’ve had too many.”
5:52 Question: “Do you think you could lead Ohio State to a national championship?” “I’m just trying to make it to tomorrow. Wow, I don’t know.”
5:56 “The players didn’t choose me, I chose them”
Alright, I’m going to eat dinner. I cannot say how excited I am at this moment. I am about to GO HARD on this dinner right now.
Michigan outlasts Ohio State, 40-34
… and does something neither of my sons have ever experienced: having to see their father (and grandfather) totally crushed after a Michigan loss. I hope, for their sake, they never have to see that again.
I guess you can’t win them all. As far as this blog is concerned, though, they almost did. They went toe-to-toe with a more experienced Michigan team, took every punch Michigan could muster and STILL had a chance at the end.
But as the season closes, we see there just wasn’t enough steam left. This team was battered by the media over and over before the season even lifted off. They had to see their coach resign admist a scandal that now sure looks a lot less severe than it did seven months ago. And they suffered through not playing with their best teammates. They fought when they could have folded.
In the end, it was just wasn’t enough.
Luke Fickell didn’t have enough time to become a head coach. It was clear that he was being groomed to be the heir apparent. Fickell is a Buckeye through-and-through and was being mentored by the best. But then he was thrust onto the throne, forced to take the keys of a kingdom he wasn’t ready for. It was clear he was not in total control of this team. From coaching gaffes (what happened on that third and six play when Miller killed the clock? Why did he save those time outs in Miami? Why didn’t he use them when Nebraska was running wild over his defense? Why did he wait so long to let Miller take over? Why wasn’t Ryan Shazier on the field until injury forced him out there?) that probably weren’t entirely his fault, it was evident he wasn’t pulling all the strings. His comments about his coaching staff proved as much. In the end, he wasn’t ready. His preparation wasn’t enough.
For a defense that had been so dominant at times, it wasn’t enough. Surely this defense, the same defense that shut down the mighty Wisconsin Badgers, would have little trouble shutting down the diminutive Denard Robinson. But they didn’t. Tackling fundamentals seemed to have been forgotten. Simon and Hankins had been neutralized. And for Ryan Shazier, a revelation on defense and certainly the x-factor in the “who can stop Robinson?” equation, didn’t have enough time on a healthy ankle.
The refs didn’t have enough yellow flags. They came out at a critical time at the end which sure made for an exciting game but there should have been more laundry on the ground in the first three quarters. This isn’t sour grapes. This is factual evidence I spied with my two little eyes.
And ultimately, Braxton Miller didn’t have enough reps. Didn’t have enough chances, in game situations, to figure out how to complete the long pass down the field. DeVier Posey didn’t have enough time to build that relationship with Miller. How quickly this game changes if those passes are completed. This loss is not Miller’s fault. His heroics will not be forgotten. He should have been afforded more chances during the season. The ones he had weren’t enough.
Many of these issues were season long, not limited to the fourth quarter against Michigan, down six points. But the culmination of this season peaked in those final minutes. And ended in the only way it could — a six win, six loss season. Five of those losses by less than a touchdown. With Tressel, those close ones go our way. With Fickell, they didn’t. The Buckeyes were never at “full strength” — starting with the loss of Nathan Williams and continuing through the suspensions of Herron, Adams and Posey. There simply wasn’t enough time.
And now we look to the future. SYR and I had a chat this morning about how we have never been so excited about anything after a crushing loss to Michigan. A new coach has been hired*. New recruits are flying in. There is a young, extremely promising quarterback. There are multiple young, promising defensive players. All have passed through a baptism by fire and will be primed for a strong run in the coming seasons.
And this time, there will be enough.

