Mid-BigTen Season Basketball Grades: Part 1

Block O.bmpThe buckeye basketball season is entering the fourth quarter, while the Big Ten season is at the midway point. March Madness is only a month away. I know it is too late for true mid-season grades, but here is a brief player by player analysis of the basketball season to date. This will be a three part analysis.

Part One: Mike Conley Jr., Jamar Butler, and Ron Lewis
Part Two: Ivan Harris, Daequan Cook, and David Lighty
Part Three: Greg Oden, Othello Hunter, and Matt Terwilliger

Feel free to add your grades and evaluation in the comments section. Also, check back after the Big Ten Tournament for a full season evaluation as a lead up to the tournament.

Mike Conley Jr.jpgMike Conley, Jr: A-
I think Conley has been the most consistent player for the Buckeyes this year. His quickness and change of direction is incredible. I am also amazed at his ability to drive the lane and shoot with either hand. I know he is a lefty but he can make the 10-12 foot runner with his right. Conley is the floor general, the catalyst that makes the offense run if you will. I know it’s cliche, but for a freshman Conley has tremendous poise. Just think, he is only going to get better. In my mind he receives a minus for suspect free throw shooting.

Jamar Butler.jpgJamar Butler: B
If Jamar’s grade was based only on the Big Ten season it would be an A; however, it took a few games for Jamar to feel comfortable in his new role as more of a 2 guard. In the last few games he has really improved his play. I think Jamar has embraced his new role. In the past Butler was the one to penetrate the defense, but now he is often the man on the wing spotting up for the three. Butler is lights out from 3 and is developing a good chemistry with Conley, Jr. Jamar will be key if the Buckeyes are to make a deep run in March.

Ron Lewis 2.jpgRon Lewis: B-
Lewis has been streaky this year to say the least. He has gone from dropping 30 on North Carolina to spotty shooting in recent games. I think Lewis is the one player most affected by Oden’s return to the line-up. Pre-Oden the lane was often clear which set up nice for Ron’s slashing style, but Oden’s presence has caused Lewis to pick the right spots to take it to the bucket.

It is hard to be critical of a team that has only lost three games this season, but let’s hope the players only continue to improve within the team concept. Hopefully they will be peaking at the right time in March. Stay tuned this week for the rest of the grades.

Should I Stay or Should I Go?

OSU LogoWill Greg Oden be a Buckeye for more than one season? That debate, to most, is a forgone conclusion. Answer: it will be one and done for the big man. In a recent interview captured by the Ozone Oden casts some light on the debate.

“There’s a very big chance I will be here four years. I’ve got to finish college. That’s what my mom told me,” Oden said.

Greg OdenBuckeye fans must remember, it is December and Oden has played in 3 games in a Buckeye uniform. Let’s not get too excited (yet). He is saying this now because it is the right thing to say and maybe he truly believes it today. It will be more difficult after the season to say the same thing when million$ are staring him in the face. Regardless of how long Oden suits up in the scarlet and gray, let’s enjoy these stats (only to get better) while we can. In three games, without full strength in his dominant hand…WOW! Average per game:

    Minutes: 24
    Points: 14.7
    Rebounds: 8.3
    Blocks: 5
    Field Goal %: 89.5

Don’t get me wrong, I am just as excited about the other freshman, but a dominant man in the middle makes all the difference thus all the discussion. What are your thoughts on Oden and the basketball Buckeyes so far?

On tap this week:
Tonight, 12/19, Iowa State in is town. Game starts at 8:00pm.
Saturday, 12/23, the Buckeyes travel to Gainesville to take on the Gators. Game starts at 4:00pm.

Ohio State = #1

OSU LogoThe college football regular season is ending this Saturday and we will soon find out the opponent for the Buckeyes in the National Championship Game. Also, we are more than a week removed from the Michigan game and Buckeye fans are coming down from the high, as Kaiser said. As a fan of the Buckeyes or a sports fan in general, there is still a lot to be excited about as we begin the six week build up to Glendale. The national championship ticket lottery has started for faculty, staff, and students. Sean, @ the 614, discusses his frustration with the process, sorry about your luck Sean. The Troy Smith college football award season is just around the corner. The bowl season begins soon. The who’s #2 debate will continue for another week (and probably beyond). Oh yeah, and there is another #1 team in Columbus, Ohio. In the ESPN/USA Today Coaches Poll the Basketball Buckeyes are ranked #1, marking only the 3rd time ever and the first time in 33 years that a football and basketball team from the same university are both ranked #1. (H/T Columbus Dispatch).

In my opinion, the ranking is a credit to the brilliant recruiting job by Thad Matta. It is too early to tell if the ranking is justified; however, there is no questioning that the team has talent and it is nice to be recognized for it. Undoubtedly the #1 ranking will bounce around to a few different teams throughout the season, but as for now the Buckeyes are kings of the college football and basketball worlds.

The Buckeye basketball season can be broken down into four segments: the non-conference warm-ups, the non-conference tests (with a couple of warm-ups mixed in), the Big Ten Season, and the post season. Thad Matta and his team have passed the first segment with an A, compiling a 6-0 record. The second segment begins tomorrow night with a battle against #6 North Carolina. The second segment, as I’m calling it, is full of games that will get the Buckeyes battle tested for a run at the Big Ten Championship and ultimately a run through March Madness. In the next month or so the Buckeyes will face UNC, Cincinnati (even in a down year should be a tough match-up), and reigning national champ Florida. Not to mention the first three games of the Big Ten season are against three of the best teams in the conference: Indiana, @ Illinois, and @ Wisconsin.

North Carolina and Florida are getting a lot of love by so called experts predictions for the Final Four and National Championship. The Buckeyes will face both teams on the road. Unfortunately, for the game against UNC tomorrow, the Buckeyes are still without Greg Oden. It is still up in the air if Oden will make his debut in time for the game against Florida.

As for Wednesday’s match-up against UNC…

Thad 5 It is no secret that Ohio State and UNC have two of the best (if not the best) recruiting classes this season. Matta’s class has been dubbed the Thad 5. On the ESPN family of networks (where the game will be televised), I have heard tomorrow’s OSU vs. UNC game hyped as such. I am excited to see how the new freshman will react in a hostile road game. There may not be national championship implications in one specific game, but in my mind this is a huge test for the development of the Thad 5.

It is time for Columbus Buckeye nation to get excited about Buckeye basketball.

OSU vs. Indiana on ESPNU ONLY!

Well Buckeye fans, unless you have ESPNU you will not be able to watch the Indiana game on October 21st. Click here for details.

Update: According to SYR, ESPNU is not available via Time Warner. Looks like those with out a dish are out of luck.

Report from Monday’s Open Practice

Autograph Session

OSU FootballAn estimated 28,000 showed up for the autograph session and practice at Ohio Stadium Monday night. I was one of those crazy people that ventured to the shoe to watch the practice, yes practice! I did not really have high expectations (which ended up being a good thing as the practice itself was mostly uneventful), but my curiosity got the best of me and I had to watch. For those who did not attend (and even if you did) here is brief overview of the events Monday night.

The evening began when the gates opened at 6pm. This gave people an hour to figure out where they wanted to stand in line for the autographs. I arrived at 7, right as the autograph session began. The concourse was filled with people waiting in lines for the autographs, thousands upon thousands of people standing in ridiculous lines. All I needed was my camera and I walked up to the tables (by passing the lines) and snapped a few photos. No wait, No drunken tailgaters breathing down my neck, and best of all I was out of there by 7:30 to find my seat to watch practice. As the old saying goes, a picture is worth a thousand words, so who needs a signature? Here are a few of the photos of my trip around the concourse and if you are so inclined here are a few more.

Troy Smith and Jim Tressel Troy Smith and Coach Jim Tressel

Ted Ginn Ted Ginn Jr.

David Patterson and Antonio PittmanDavid Patterson and Antonio Pittman

Jay Richardson and Quinn Pitcock Jay Richardson and Quinn Pitcock

Dionte Johnson, Vernon Gholston, and John Kerr Dionte Johnson, Vernon Gholston, and John Kerr

Practice

The practice time was split up into three parts. The first third of the practice focused on special teams, beginning with the punt, followed by the kickoff, and then field goals. Coach Tressel was right in the middle of the action directing traffic. Another reminder of how important special teams are to the success of the team. Highlights:

  • In the span of five minutes, Anderson Russell blocked two punts.
  • Aaron Pettrey nailed a 54 yard field goal (below) that would have been good from 60 yards. More on that in the observations below.
  • The second part of practice separated the passing game and the running game. On one side of the field there were one on one drills with the wide receivers and defensive backs, and on the other side of the field the rest of the team practiced the running game. Highlights:

  • There was some speed displayed during the one on one drills. The wide receivers and defensive backs are fast.
  • This may be preaching to the choir, but Troy Smith can make any throw. He has got a gun.
  • In the final part of practice we saw the offense take on the defense in some 11 on 11 drills. This was not a scrimmage, so there was not full contact. The practice session concluded with some live (using the clock) two minute drills. Each of the first three string offenses and defenses squared off. The defense was given 2 points and it was up to the offense to at least get into field goal range, starting from their own 45 yard line, in order to “win”. Highlights:

  • First Team O vs. First Team D: The offense managed one first down and with 5 seconds left attempted a 54 yard field goal by Ryan Pretorius, which fell miserably short. More on that in the observations below. Defense “wins”.
  • Second Team O vs. Second Team D: On the third play of the drill, Kurt Coleman picks off a Justin Zwick pass and returns it for a TD. Defense “wins”.
  • Third Team O vs. Third Team D: The offense ran four plays and could not convert a first down. Defense “wins”.
  • Three General Observations

    The more I see and hear about OSU’s defense, the less worried I become about replacing nine starters. There is talent and speed-o-plenty out there on the field.

    OSU is going to be solid at QB for years to come. There may not be a Heisman hyped QB after this year for a while, but I am definitely not worried about that position at all. The young kids, Boeckman, Schoenhoft, and Henton look good.

    Finally, the place kicker battle is uber important this week. Ryan Pretorius and Aaron Pettrey are locked in a battle for the starting spot. From what I saw on Monday night, Pettrey has a much stronger leg than Pretorius. I believe the battle will be decided by who the coaches believe can be more consistent. Wednesday’s kick scrimmage will almost surely decide who will win the job. It is the kicker’s day to shine. By all means they need that time, since most of their practice was spent on the sidelines watching. Oh the life of a lonesome kicker.

    2006-2007 Buckeye Men’s Basketball Schedule Announced

    Gren Oden 2 I realize it is football season and not many people, especially in Columbus, care about basketball right now. I promise this is the one and only time I will mention the upcoming basketball season (until football is over). I just had to give some credit to Thad Matta and Gene Smith for trying to make basketball matter in Columbus. Sure basketball will always be secondary to football in this town, but with this year’s recruiting class (highlighted by Greg Oden) and newly released schedule, there is reason for fans to get excited.

    Thad MattaThis year’s schedule includes non-conference games against North Carolina, Cincinnati, Tennessee, and defending national champ Florida. These games will give tOSU basketball program national exposure. It has been said by Matta and others in OSU’s basketball circle that they are interested in building a basketball powerhouse at Ohio State. This is not a one season get all the publicity you can and who cares what happens next thing. Matta is building something special for the present and the future. Matta said the schedule was made with long-term goals in mind:

    “This is an incredibly challenging schedule for our young basketball team,” Matta said. “We will be short-handed and inexperienced in the beginning. But I believe the competitiveness of who we are playing, where we are playing and when we are playing will make us a better basketball team in the long run.”

    There will be plenty of time and the right (not football) season to discuss much more OSU basketball. I wanted to give a shout out to Matta for doing an amazing job and the new schedule provided that opportunity. Forgive me for interrupting your football reading.

    Buckeyes Preseason #1 in USA Today Coaches Poll

    FootballThe first installment of the USA Today Coaches Poll has been released and the Buckeyes find themselves at #1. The national media articles I have read today all begin with a similar sentence: Despite having lost 9 starters on defense, the Buckeyes are #1 in the coaches poll. After reading all three parts of our defensive preview, in which we previewed the linebackers, secondary and D-line, it is apparent that we are not too worried about the defense stepping up this year. The coaches showed me that they agree by voting the Buckeyes #1. As the old saying goes, OSU does not rebuild — it reloads.

    You don’t have to look very far down the poll to understand how big the game Sept. 9th in Austin, TX will be this year. In fact, you can stop at #2. Amongst ourselves here at MotSaG, we think Texas is slightly overrated, but we understand they are garnering respect for being the defending National Champs. Losing a star QB is huge (especially when your new QB has never played a game in college), and let’s face it, Vince Young single-handedly won Texas the championship.

    Does it get any better than this?

    With all do respect to Northern Illinois and North Texas, only in their wildest dreams are they going to upset the Buckeyes or the Longhorns in week one. We are going to see a showdown of #1 OSU vs. #2 UT on 9/9. The game, as it did last year in Columbus, will go a long way in deciding who plays in the national championship game this season.

    2006 Defensive Preview – Secondary

    OSU Football Our defensive preview continues with a look at the defensive backs. OSU’s secondary will be replacing all four starters from a year ago. The new players, for the most part, are unproven and untested in game situations. Second year coaches Tim Beckman (cornerbacks) and Paul Haynes (safties), do not have much time to make these players a cohesive unit. Sept 9th will be here before we know it, and even without Vince Young our players will face a huge test. We are not trying to downplay the importance of the season opener, but OSU plays N. Illinois at home. On the road, at night, will go a long way in determining how well the relatively new DB coaches and players continue to adapt to big time college football. (It is too early for a prediction, but revenge will taste so sweet). Here’s a look at the top two players at each position going into training camp this fall and a talented incoming freshman to keep an eye on.

    Left Cornerback

    Malcolm JenkinsMalcolm Jenkins (6-1, 202, So.) – As a true freshman, Jenkins started four games last year because of an injury to then starter Tyler Everett. This year, with those starts under his belt and an off-season where he added 15 pounds, Jenkins will have added responsibility. He will, on most occasions, be asked to cover the opponent’s best receiver. I expect with OSU’s inexperience at DB, teams will try to throw on the defense early and often, testing our young secondary. Jenkins, after not being highly recruited out of high school, is poised to show what a lot of schools missed. He has high hopes of becoming the next great cornerback from Ohio State. He has the size, ability, and speed to be great, but time will tell how great he will be.

    Andre AmosAndre Amos (6-1, 180, R-Fr.) – Amos, a converted wide receiver, goes into the fall as the backup to Jenkins. After red-shirting last year, Amos has not played a down in college (a theme that will be repeated throughout the secondary). Amos will add important depth to a young corps of cornerbacks. He will compete for playing time as the Nickel corner, but look for him mainly on special teams this year.

    Right Cornerback

    Antonio Smith (5-9, 195, Sr.) – Antonio Smith, a former walk-on from Beechcroft High School here in Columbus, has paid his dues at Ohio State, having now earned his scholarship. Antonio has been a strong contributor on special teams, and this year he will get his shot to be a starter for the Buckeye’s defense. At first glance, Antonio does not look the part of a cornerback (as evidenced by the picture, have you ever seen a cornerback wear a neck brace?). He started his career at OSU listed as a strong safety and was known for his hard-hitting. Over the years he has developed his cover skills. Standing only 5-9, he will use his quickness and smarts to challenge and out-think the receivers. He won’t be the next Antoine Winfield, but assuming he continues on top of the depth chart, look for Antonio to provide senior leadership to the young defensive backfield.

    Donald WashingtonDonald Washington (6-1, 195, R-Fr.) – Washington, like Andre Amos, red-shirted last year. Another backup corner that has not seen a snap in college, Washington will play the same role as Amos; however, due to the lack of Antonio Smith’s experience, having never started a game either, Washington may be in the mix for more playing time.

    Strong Safety

    Jamario O'Neal 1Jamario O’Neal (6-1, 190, So.) – O’Neal is another former player from Ohio State’s farm team, Cleveland Glenville. Jamario will be replacing top-ten draft pick, and fellow Glenville Tarblooder, Donte Whitner at strong safety. There is a lot of hype that has followed Jamario to OSU. He was ranked in the top five nationally for defensive backs and was the second best overall prospect in the state of Ohio coming out of high school. He was a regular on special teams last year as a true freshman, but this year much more will be asked of Jamario. We will quickly find out if he is worthy of all the hype. Hype drives pressure, and some people thrive under pressure while others fade. Jamario has a chance to be spectacular, here’s hoping he is one who thrives.

    Anderson RussellAnderson Russell (6-0, 190, R-Fr.) – Russell is from the same high school class as Andre Amos and Donald Washington. In effort to avoid being redundant, his role on the team will be much of the same. Russell, like the other two, will get on the field in special teams situations, but all three will need to show signs of brilliance this fall to contend for regular playing time during the season. Again, we mention the importance of building depth and Russell will help bolster the depth of this young and talented secondary.

    Free Safety

    Nick PattersonNick Patterson (6-2, 210, So.) – Patterson going into fall is listed atop the depth chart at free safety. Nick will be taking over the spot left vacant by the graduation of Nate Salley. We hope Nick will dish out as many punishing hits we came so accustomed to seeing from Salley. Patterson red-shirted in 2004 and lettered last year playing on special teams. He is yet another player that will have to step up this year to prove he is ready to start for the Buckeye defense. I have to admit I was surprised to see him listed above Brandon Mitchell on the depth chart. Patterson must be a special player to be listed in front of a senior with considerable game experience.

    Brandon MitchellBrandon Mitchell (6-3, 205, Sr.) – Brandon is one of only two seniors (along with Antonio Smith) in the Buckeye secondary, but unlike Antonio, he will bring game experience to the defense. Mitchell has started 8 and played in 33 games in his career. He will see significant playing time this season even if he is not starting. I expect to see Mitchell in the game in most nickel situations. Due to the nature of college football the young secondary will look to Mitchell for some leadership. After losing so many players from a senior-laden defense a year ago, OSU needs to find new leaders on and off the field. Mitchell has a chance to be one of those guys. Time will tell if he grabs the responsibility.

    Player to keep an eye on:

    Kurt Coleman (5-11, 185, Fr., CB) – Coleman graduated early from Northmont high school in Clayton, Ohio. He enrolled at OSU this spring and was able to participate in spring practice and the spring game. He had a strong spring, making the coaches take notice, which culminated with an nice interception in the spring game.

    That’s a look at the defensive backs ready to make an impact for the 2006 OSU Buckeyes. Unless you have memorized the depth chart in the previous year or two, there may be some names listed here that you have never heard before, or at least players not very familiar to you. Now is the time to get to know them. Love them like they are family (we, the Ohio State community are one big family anyway, right? O-H!). We are going to have to live with some mistakes. The players are raw, but man they are talented. The new players all have the size, speed, and ability to become good if not great players at OSU. It will required hard work and determination from each individual player to acheive greatness. Here are some sentiments from their new DB coaches (courtesy of the Ozone):

    “Surprisingly I think we’ll be faster in the secondary than we were last year. These guys fly around,”

    said safeties coach Paul Haynes. Cornerbacks coach Tim Beckman added:

    “We’ve got a lot of guys that can run. I think with their physicalness and the stature of each one of them, we’ve got some big kids back there, that this could be a special group. It’s up to them to take their game to the next level.”

    Nobody likes the “P” word: potential, but these guys have it. Who will be the next Mike Doss, Antoine Winifield, Nate Clements, or Shawn Springs, to name a few? Will any of them come close? Time will tell. Luckily for OSU fans there are three or four years to figure that out.

    More importantly for the 2006 season, OSU needs these young players to adapt quickly to the college game. As I said before, most of these players have not played at all (aside from special teams) in college, and only a couple have played any significant minutes. One thing OSU can hang their hat on… it can’t hurt going against the OSU offense on a daily basis come fall camp. The chance for the DBs to cover Ginn, Gonzalez, Hall, etc. will only help their development. At this point in their young careers OSU doesn’t need superstars – that will come. As long as they can be good collectively, the defense should be fine. The DBs will rely heavily on the pass rush of the front four. The more pressure on the QB, the easier the job for the DBs.

    Stayed tuned in the coming days for our preview of defensive line.