Buckeyes Storm to Commanding NCAA Wrestling Lead: @wrestlingbucks @buckeye158

Though danger definitely lurks with a deep Iowa team and top heavy Missouri team, Ohio State busted out to a commanding lead after the third of six rounds at the NCAA Wrestling Championships in St. Louis, MO. Although the Buckeyes are down to five wrestlers who are still alive, all five will be All Americans and are headed to the semifinals, live tonight on ESPN (8 Eastern).

The feel good story of the year really is Kenny Courts. Dogged by inconsistent performance in light of his clear and undeniable talent, the junior 184 pounder is one match away from wrestling on the elevated stage in tomorrow night’s finals. Coach Tom Ryan, while frustrated at times, has never wavered in his belief that Kenny had the goods to break through. Both were rewarded when Kenny hit an overtime takedown to beat Matthew McCutcheon of Penn State. Ryan suggests a gentleman upstairs might be looking out for the unseeded Kenny who, after knocking off a six seed, saw someone else knock off the eleven seed that would have been his next opponent, followed by McCutcheon who beat the third seed. It has happened yet again. His next opponent, Nathaniel Brown of Lehigh upended the two seed. The winner will go to the finals in a bracket buster no one saw coming.

The other amazing thing is this: while you can expect Logan Stieber and his freshmen gang of three (Tomasello, Jordan and Snyder) to make it to the semis, with such a big number something almost always goes wrong. Not today. Tomasello kicked the stuffing out of Corey Mines of Edinboro to earn a tech fall. Stieber did the same to Anthony Abidin of Nebraska. But then Bo Jordan PINS a Cooper Moore who pinned two guys including four seed Nick Sulzer, a guy most predicted would best Jordan.

Right after Courts’ thriller, Kyle Snyder had had a Schiller Thriller, taking down the immovable object in Scott Schiller of Minnesota. Schiller is a very strong wrestler, and a veteran but he has no ability to penetrate Snyder’s defenses. An early Snyder takedown essentially sealed the deal.

So the Buckeyes head to the semis with an astounding five wrestlers, three of whom face number one seeds and two of those, Tomasello and Snyder, face Missouri opponents. The Buckeyes will need to pull off one of those head to heads, and to stay ahead of Iowa they may need both. Of course, if Kenny Courts or Bo Jordan (who faces number one Alex Dieringer of Oklahoma State) can get to the finals, the entire equation changes for the better.

It has been a great year to be a Buckeye and now a first NCAA wrestling title is in sight. Tonight ill reveal much about where that dream stands.

From earlier:

Friday Morning

The Ohio State Wrestling Team suffered some setbacks but had a strong enough day to lead after the first full day of competition at the NCAA Championships in St. Louis’ Scottrade Arena. The story of the tournament so far is unseeded Kenny Courts who will join four others this morning in the championship bracket quarterfinals. In total, the Buckeyes have a tournament leading eight wrestlers still going, and all are going strong. Here is a repeat of the first session and a summary of the second session.

First Session:

The Ohio State Wrestling team had a very pleasant surprise, a close loss to a seeded wrestler and a genuine heartbreak. Badly injured Hunter Stieber gave it a go. Without a single usable arm he nearly missed a dramatic comeback. He looked pretty good on his feet but probably was not healthy enough to escape from the bottom in the second. That led to him getting put on his back. Although he valiantly held off a pin, the period rideout cost him the point he could have used as he gamely came back. A near takedown at the end fell short, sending the hurt fighter to the long wrestle backs, likely against last year’s NCAA runner-up Josh Kindig, who is also hurt.

On the bright side, the Buckeyes send a tournament leading seven wrestlers to the second round as they picked up bonus points on two pins (Tomasello ad Jordan), one tech fall (Logan Stieber) and one major decision (Snyder). Even better, Kenny Courts nailed an overtime takedown to score an upset over a six seed. Kennny’s would be opponent, the eleven seeded Pfarr from Minnesota was also upset, opening the possibility that the very talented but enigmatic Kenny could end up in the quarters with a win tonight.

The Buckeyes did encounter a tough loss at 174, but Mark Martin can redeem himself in the wrestlebacks. He still stands a decent chance of making the All American brackets.

The Buckeyes finished the first session in first place in the team standings. Even better, their main challengers, Iowa and Missouri had significant setbacks. Iowa, in particular lost five (141) and three (285) seeds and have only five wrestlers into the second round. Mizzou fared a little better. Although they scored two minor upsets, they also suffered one minor and one major upset when four seed Eblen lost at 174. Mizzou also sends seven to the second round but will have at least one tough match when three seed Lavion Mayes goes against Dean Heil of Oklahoma State.

The Buckeyes have particularly critical matches at 133 (Johnni DiJulius vs 17-1 thirteen seed Cody Brewrer of Oklahoma), 157, (Josh Demas v. eleven seed Brian Murphy, Michigan) and 184 (Kenny Courts v. unseeded Scott Patrick, Davidson). This is potentially a big night for the Buckeyes, who historically go on a nice run in the first evening session. Buckle up.

Second Session

The Buckeyes continued their roll by picking up a second win by Kenny Courts who dominated Davidson’s Scott Patrick at 184. Coach Ryan said he never gave up on Kenny despite a disappointing effort for much of this season. “Kenny just kept believing and now he has a huge match that he has to win this morning.” Coach Ryan allowed that a higher force is perhaps at work. Not only did Kenny knock off the sixth seed in the first round, but Patrick managed to bump off the eleven seed as well. Now he takes on 14 seed Mathew McCutcheon who beat third seeded Blake Stauffer of Arizona State. A win would put Kenny, incredibly, in the semis, something very few would have predicted.

The Buckeyes lost at 133 and 157. Johnni DiJulius was mauled for a major decision loss to Cody Brewer of Oklahoma. At 157 Josh Demas toyed agonizingly with the winning takedown over Brian Murphy of Michigan but just could not finish it off, suffering a tough one point loss. The good news is that both DiJulius and Demas have a chance to make a strong push through the wrestlebacks later this morning.

Mark Martin scored a nice win in his first round in the consolation bracket. He also has an opportunity to advance to the medal rounds as he would likely face no higher than a seven seed for several matches.

Kenny Courts will be joined in the quarters by the usual Buckeye suspects, Nathan Tomasello at 125, Logan Stieber at 141, Bo Jordan at 165 and Kyle Snyder at 197. Tomasello won a major decision in his backyard brawl with Ben Willefort of Cleveland State, while Stieber walked away with a pin and Snyder managed a 14-5 demolition of Shane Woods of Wyoming. Bo Jordan ground out a 6-2 win over Dylan Palacio of Cornell and now finds himself against thirteen seed Cooper Moore of Northern Iowa. Moore knocked off four seed Nick Sulzer of Virginia, who some experts (me not included) projected to knock off the fifth seeded Jordan.

The heartbreak continued for Hunter Stieber who made a go of it with no usable elbow. His coach mercifully threw in the towel in the middle of a match with a gracious Clayton Ream of North Dakota State. As the Ohio State partisans rose to their feet in admiration and tribute, Hunter left the mat knowing double elbow surgery awaits him next week. Hunter gave every ounce of effort his pain wracked body could offer.

At heavy, Nick Tavanello once again gave up a last second takedwon to Brooks Black to become the second Buckeye eliminated from contention.

The team scores show Ohio State in the lead at 23. Iowa trails by two points. Although they also have five wrestlers in the quarters, three of them face long odds: Thomas Gilman goes against third seeded Joey Vance of Virginia Tech at 125; Sam Brooks faces number one seed Gabe Dean of Cornell at 184 and Nathan Burak faces third seeded Kyven Gadsen of Iowa State at 197. What is more, Mike Evans may be third seeded at 174 but he goes against sixth seed Logan Storley of Minnesota who beat Evans for third at the Big Ten two weeks ago. Corey Clark faces a pretty tough sixth seed Earl Hall of Iowa State at 133 as well.

Missouri suffered a number of setbacks but still has all three number one seeds going. Assuming Ohio State can win this morning at 125 and 197, that could set up two titanic matches in the semis tonight as Tomasello would go against Missouri’s one seed Alan Waters and Kyle Snyder would go against Missouri’s defending national champ J’Den Cox. Before that though, Snyder will once again need to beat the very tough fifth seed, Scott Schiller of Minnesota.

Buckeyes Eye National Title After Day One of NCAA Wrestling Championships

The Ohio State Wrestling Team suffered some setbacks but had a strong enough day to lead after the first full day of competition at the NCAA Championships in St. Louis’ Scottrade Arena. The story of the tournament so far is unseeded Kenny Courts who will join four others this morning in the championship bracket quarterfinals. In total, the Buckeyes have a tournament leading eight wrestlers still going, and all are going strong. Here is a repeat of the first session and a summary of the second session.

First Session:

The Ohio State Wrestling team had a very pleasant surprise, a close loss to a seeded wrestler and a genuine heartbreak. Badly injured Hunter Stieber gave it a go. Without a single usable arm he nearly missed a dramatic comeback. He looked pretty good on his feet but probably was not healthy enough to escape from the bottom in the second. That led to him getting put on his back. Although he valiantly held off a pin, the period rideout cost him the point he could have used as he gamely came back. A near takedown at the end fell short, sending the hurt fighter to the long wrestle backs, likely against last year’s NCAA runner-up Josh Kindig, who is also hurt.

On the bright side, the Buckeyes send a tournament leading seven wrestlers to the second round as they picked up bonus points on two pins (Tomasello ad Jordan), one tech fall (Logan Stieber) and one major decision (Snyder). Even better, Kenny Courts nailed an overtime takedown to score an upset over a six seed. Kennny’s would be opponent, the eleven seeded Pfarr from Minnesota was also upset, opening the possibility that the very talented but enigmatic Kenny could end up in the quarters with a win tonight.

The Buckeyes did encounter a tough loss at 174, but Mark Martin can redeem himself in the wrestlebacks. He still stands a decent chance of making the All American brackets.

The Buckeyes finished the first session in first place in the team standings. Even better, their main challengers, Iowa and Missouri had significant setbacks. Iowa, in particular lost five (141) and three (285) seeds and have only five wrestlers into the second round. Mizzou fared a little better. Although they scored two minor upsets, they also suffered one minor and one major upset when four seed Eblen lost at 174. Mizzou also sends seven to the second round but will have at least one tough match when three seed Lavion Mayes goes against Dean Heil of Oklahoma State.

The Buckeyes have particularly critical matches at 133 (Johnni DiJulius vs 17-1 thirteen seed Cody Brewrer of Oklahoma), 157, (Josh Demas v. eleven seed Brian Murphy, Michigan) and 184 (Kenny Courts v. unseeded Scott Patrick, Davidson). This is potentially a big night for the Buckeyes, who historically go on a nice run in the first evening session. Buckle up.

Second Session

The Buckeyes continued their roll by picking up a second win by Kenny Courts who dominated Davidson’s Scott Patrick at 184. Coach Ryan said he never gave up on Kenny despite a disappointing effort for much of this season. “Kenny just kept believing and now he has a huge match that he has to win this morning.” Coach Ryan allowed that a higher force is perhaps at work. Not only did Kenny knock off the sixth seed in the first round, but Patrick managed to bump off the eleven seed as well. Now he takes on 14 seed Mathew McCutcheon who beat third seeded Blake Stauffer of Arizona State. A win would put Kenny, incredibly, in the semis, something very few would have predicted.

The Buckeyes lost at 133 and 157. Johnni DiJulius was mauled for a major decision loss to Cody Brewer of Oklahoma. At 157 Josh Demas toyed agonizingly with the winning takedown over Brian Murphy of Michigan but just could not finish it off, suffering a tough one point loss. The good news is that both DiJulius and Demas have a chance to make a strong push through the wrestlebacks later this morning.

Mark Martin scored a nice win in his first round in the consolation bracket. He also has an opportunity to advance to the medal rounds as he would likely face no higher than a seven seed for several matches.

Kenny Courts will be joined in the quarters by the usual Buckeye suspects, Nathan Tomasello at 125, Logan Stieber at 141, Bo Jordan at 165 and Kyle Snyder at 197. Tomasello won a major decision in his backyard brawl with Ben Willefort of Cleveland State, while Stieber walked away with a pin and Snyder managed a 14-5 demolition of Shane Woods of Wyoming. Bo Jordan ground out a 6-2 win over Dylan Palacio of Cornell and now finds himself against thirteen seed Cooper Moore of Northern Iowa. Moore knocked off four seed Nick Sulzer of Virginia, who some experts (me not included) projected to knock off the fifth seeded Jordan.

The heartbreak continued for Hunter Stieber who made a go of it with no usable elbow. His coach mercifully threw in the towel in the middle of a match with a gracious Clayton Ream of North Dakota State. As the Ohio State partisans rose to their feet in admiration and tribute, Hunter left the mat knowing double elbow surgery awaits him next week. Hunter gave every ounce of effort his pain wracked body could offer.

At heavy, Nick Tavanello once again gave up a last second takedwon to Brooks Black to become the second Buckeye eliminated from contention.

The team scores show Ohio State in the lead at 23. Iowa trails by two points. Although they also have five wrestlers in the quarters, three of them face long odds: Thomas Gilman goes against third seeded Joey Vance of Virginia Tech at 125; Sam Brooks faces number one seed Gabe Dean of Cornell at 184 and Nathan Burak faces third seeded Kyven Gadsen of Iowa State at 197. What is more, Mike Evans may be third seeded at 174 but he goes against sixth seed Logan Storley of Minnesota who beat Evans for third at the Big Ten two weeks ago. Corey Clark faces a pretty tough sixth seed Earl Hall of Iowa State at 133 as well.

Missouri suffered a number of setbacks but still has all three number one seeds going. Assuming Ohio State can win this morning at 125 and 197, that could set up two titanic matches in the semis tonight as Tomasello would go against Missouri’s one seed Alan Waters and Kyle Snyder would go against Missouri’s defending national champ J’Den Cox. Before that though, Snyder will once again need to beat the very tough fifth seed, Scott Schiller of Minnesota.

Ohio State NCAA Wrestling Math

INTRODUCTION/SCORING BREAKDOWN
The biggest reason why Ohio State was able to claim a share of its first Big Ten wrestling title in 64 years was the ascension of 125 pounder Nathan Tomasello. It shouldn’t come as a surprise then that the biggest opportunity for OSU to win an NCAA title this week in St. Louis also belongs to Nathan Tomasello. Let’s look at the math bracketology of wrestling to break this down.

Eight place wrestling tournaments award points based on the following placements:
1st place: 16 team points
2nd place: 12 team points
3rd place: 10 team points
4th place: 9 team points
5th place: 7 team points
6th place: 6 team points
7th place: 5 team points
8th place: 3 team points

A full point is also awarded for each advancement in the championship bracket and a half point is awarded for advancement in the consolation bracket. Two “bonus” points are added for each fall or forfeit, 1.5 is awarded for a 15 point tech fall with back points, and 1 point is added for an 8 or more major decision or a tech fall with no back points.

OBSERVATION FROM BIG TEN TOURNAMENT

Ignoring advancement and bonus points, if you add up the placement points that were projected based on the seeding of each wrestler, Iowa was projected to earn 99 points in the Big Ten Tournament, Ohio State was projected to earn 96 and Minnesota was projected to earn 82. Ohio State and Iowa tied at 120, a number which included advancement and bonus points. But if you look just at the placement points you find that while Ohio State fell six short of its projected 96 points, Iowa fell a whopping fourteen points short of projection. It was those eight extra points off the Iowa board that kept them from claiming the outright title.

There are many different changes back and forth between projected and actual, but the most dramatic in terms of the team standings was at 125. By beating number one Thomas Gilman of Iowa, third seeded Tomasello added four team points from the twelve he would have earned for second (which came after his dramatic semi-final win against two time NCAA champ Jesse Delgado of Illinois) and dropped the four extra from Iowa that Gilman was projected to earn. That eight point swing total was exactly the difference that accounted for the team tie.

From the Iowa perspective, it also hurt that they won none of their three projected number one finishes, including at 125. That cost them a total of twelve team points. While Ohio State managed to win only one of its three number one projected finishes, they picked up a title from the third seeded Tomasello. When you take away the difference in points for the two projected winners who finished second (Jordan and Snyder at 165 and 197) but add the difference between the third place Tomasello was projected to earn and the first place points he actually did earn, Ohio State only lost two points in the consideration of projected vs actual first place points.

Two other Ohio State wrestlers scored critical points necessary to pull off the team title. At 157, Josh Demas was seeded sixth but upped his game to finish fourth, losing twice to tough but enigmatic James Green of Nebraska. At 174, Mark Martin bested his sixth place seed and scored the last meet tying point by hitting a dramatic sudden victory overtime takedown to claim fifth place points.

Kenny Courts was seeded fifth but finished eighth—a disappointing finish for sure, but the handful of total points he earned were obviously needed for the team win.

And then of course there was Hunter Stieber. He was assigned a charitable third seed out of respect for a former third place NCAA finisher and Big Ten Champion. With two badly injured elbows it was pretty miraculous he made it to the semifinals, but nothing short of heroic that he even attempted to wrestle in the consolation semis. He was pinned by a mediocre wrestler who gave a super bowl winning exalt over beating the courageous Stieber, but Hunter’s eventual sixth place points were unexpected gold at 149 pounds.

LOOKING FORWARD TO THE NCAAs

In looking at the NCAA seeds, and taking into account the championship bracket placement points the seeding projects, you find that Missouri, without regard to bonus or consolation advancement points, would be the NCAA team champion with 86 projected points. Iowa projects second at 77 points and Ohio State projects three points behind Iowa. It should be noted that Ohio State has all ten wrestlers going whereas Iowa and Missouri have only eight each. And those two extra wrestlers have the potential to rack up points that could close the gap. More on that below.

But once again, the biggest difference is at 125 where Nathan Tomasello is seeded fourth and Alan Waters of Missouri is seeded first. If all goes according to plan, those two would meet in the semifinals. Ah, but will things go according to plan? To get there, Tomasello would have to beat unseeded Joe DeAngelo, North Carolina State, and the winner of unseeded Ethan LIzak, Minnesota and thirteenth seed Ben Willeford. He would then likely meet up with fifth seed Sean Boyle of Chattanooga. Nothing is easy in wrestling, but that would seem manageable.

If you just go by the seeding, you would think Waters would face either the 16th seed or Conor Youtsey of Michigan in his second match, and either a very tough Dylan Peters of Northern Iowa (ninth seed) or eighth seed Tyler Cox of Wyoming. But wait a second—hiding there unseeded is two time defending national champion Jesse Delgado who would face the eight and nine seeds before possibly getting to Waters. True, Delgado has been hurt much of the year, but he has been back six weeks. He looked pretty good against Tomasello. Although he finished fourth in the Big Ten (in a third place match he probably did not care much about), he will have had two extra weeks to get ready.

What I am suggesting is that it is very possible Waters will go against a two time defending champ in his match to get to Tomasello. Waters will have his hands full.

But assuming it does work out for Waters and he gets to Tomasello, if Tomasello can pull the upset, even if Waters goes on to finish third and Tomasello finishes second, Ohio State and Missouri would be tied at 78 points. The two wrestlers met in December. Tomasello had a bad habit then of beating on his higher ranked opponents but getting caught for back points. This was true against Waters and Joey Dance of Virginia Tech. He even was pinned after mauling Dylan Peters for most of the match. But still, Tomasello came storming back against Waters to make it a nailbiter.

Both wrestlers have advanced quite a bit since then, but it is easy to see a Tomasello upset. If Tomasello cannot make the difference, another key Missouri / Ohio State one vs four matchup awaits.

Kyle Snyder ended up with a four seed at 197 thanks to his being mildly upset in the Big Ten finals. Assuming he can get past a very tough five seed Scott Schiller of Minnesota, Kyle would meet defending NCAA champ J’Den Cox, of Missouri. It’s a tall order for Snyder to beat Cox, but it is definitely possible—the top handful of guys in this class are all within 2 points of each other. The two have been on apparent collision courses twice this year but the meet-ups never happened. Obviously, this potential head to head is also key for the team race. If Tomasello and Snyder both deliver the upsets, a few other things can go wrong and the Buckeyes could still win the title. But it seems likely the Buckeyes need a win in one of these two matches—if they happen.

What else to watch for from the Buckeyes? At 133 in the Big Ten, Johnni DiJulius held serve with a fourth place finish from his fourth seed. He is also seed fourth at the NCAA. From the beginning of the year, Johnni has been my dark horse candidate to sprint into the NCAA finals. It is an uphill battle. Johnni is on the cusp of breaking through but this is a closely matched weight class. While Johnni could make it to the finals, he could also get knocked out completely. Buckeye fans really need him to finish close to or above his seeding.

As noted, Josh Demas wrestled very well at the Big Ten, losing only to a very good James Green. If Josh wrestles with his late blossoming fury (he has had a long journey back from injury), he should make it to the quarterfinal match against Dylan Ness. Ness is a really tough and explosive wrestler. Although Ness generally bests Green, Demas actually matches up better with Ness. I call it a long shot, but Josh can punch through here—and if he does, I think he is a candidate to make it to the finals. If that happens, all bets are off—this is the kind of gold the Buckeyes can only dream of, but if Josh wrestles like his hair is on fire, this is possible.

Mark Martin goes in as a ten seed, but Mark also wrestled very well in the Big Ten. He had a pretty mediocre season but his fifth place win at the Big Ten revealed an anger and resentment for the lack of respect he has earned. He really had the fierce Logan Storley on the ropes. That would be signature win unraveled with late match carelessness, but the Big Ten leaves you thinking Martin may have found some late season fire.

Kenny Courts is the enigma of the team. His talent at 184 is undeniable but he clearly has an execution and focus problem. He just seems to get lost. He has an incredible ankle pick from neutral. In high school all he had to do was reel in those ankles, but that really isn’t classic technique. To avoid a cross face and pancake, wrestlers are taught to get a leg and then get perpendicular. Kenny gets in like no one else, but then routinely loses the takedown as guys just muscle out of his parallel hold. He has a granby roll that is beautiful to watch but he always seems lost about what to do next. It is a shame. Nice kid, great technique, but it just seems he is overmatched (relative to his ability–he has won 22 matches after all) in the college game. But as only one of three Ohio State non-seeds, if he could somehow rise to his talent, he could also add points that the seeds don’t project.

It only seems like heavy Nick Tavanello hasn’t won since the Kennedy Administration. With a season messed up due to a knee injury, Nick received an at-large NCAA bid, most certainly because of his mad dash through the consolation bracket in last year’s NCAAs. I am guessing the OSU coaches successfully argued Nick is healthy and only needs more conditioning to get to where he was last year. I am sure Nick is tormented by a last second takedown by trip that cost him a place on the Big Ten podium and denied the outright conference crown to the Buckeyes. A run resembling anything like last year’s would also be found gold to the Buckeyes.

At this point, let me note something for the record. The Buckeyes have wrestled all year with the late Kosta Karageorge’s initials sewn into their singlets. It is entirely possible a healthy Karageorge would have wrestled in the Big Ten and this week. I’m not saying anything other than, with Nick’s injury Kosta would have competed, and it is anyone’s guess how that would have played out.

So what about the Big 3 remianing? Logan Stieber is a very big favorite to win his fourth NCAA title, but the journey has two interesting elements to it. Stieber has always delivered huge bonus points. This year should be no different, but it got a little tougher than it should have. Lavion Mayes of Missouri was somewhat inexplicably awarded a third seed—pushing him out of Stieber’s path to the finals, and pushing four seed Devin Carter of Virginia Tech into it. Stieber mauled Cater en route to a December major win in Las Vegas. But Carter is a returning NCAA finalist and is going to be no easy touch for Stieber. (Of course, if Mayes is overseeded, guys like Nick Dardanes potentially await. Thus, there is upset potential with an OSU opportunity to close the gap with MIzzou in the team race—watch that Dardanes match-up.)

No one gives Bo Jordan a chance to get to the finals at 165 but what does no one know, really? Jordan ended up with a fifth seed as fallout from his loss to cousin Jordan in the Big Ten finals. For him to make the NCAA finals he would have to beat four seed Nick Sulzer of Virginia and undefeated one seed Alex Dierenger of Oklahoma State. I’m not sure how you can rule Jordan out of any match. He has only lost once and that was by the narrowest of margins. I’m not sure I would call Sulzer a favorite and it would not shock me at all to see Jordan upend Dierenger. Here is a chance to raise the Buckeye ceiling.

Finally there is Hunter Stieber. After watching how helpless he was last week I don’t see how he can be competitive this week. Elbows take many months to heal. What I will say is he wrestled without tape in the match he lost—it is possible tape and rest could help. But in winning his first two matches in the Big Ten, he looked comfortable and confident. He did seem to tire at the end (though he manged a winning two point reversal at the very end of his quarterfinal match), but he had the smooth look of the champion he has been, not the rusty look you would have expected.

Hunter lands in a bracket against a fourteen seed. If he pulls that off somehow, he will get the winner of third seed David Habat of Edinboro or last year’s NCAA runner-up Josh Kindig of Oklahoma State. Kindig has been injured and did not wrestle in his conference tournament. Either way, if Hunter can cobble a competitive effort, this will be an early chance to strike paydirt. I just don’t think his elbows can handle the long grind of an early trip to the consolation bracket.

Bottom line: the Buckeyes need to hold serve on their seeds and have an upset by Tomasello or Snyder in the semis. If they get both, break out whatever college students are allowed to enjoy in celebration. If they fall short in both, the Buckeyes are going to need a couple of shockers like DiJulius and Demas reaching the finals. Anything they get from Courts, Tavanello and Hunter Stieber will relieve pressure, but they are going to need big things to happen at the top of some brackets, both in their favor and against Missouri. I have not forgotten about Iowa but if Ohio State takes care of these kind of things they should get past the Hawkeyes absent an epic run of their own.

Thoughts About Buckeye Big Ten Wrestling Championship

I may be old –ok no “may be” about it—I’m ancient. But I am young enough that until today the wrestling team of The Ohio State University had never in my lifetime won The Big Ten title—the toughest conference in America—by far. They actually won it Sunday by tying Iowa at 120 points each, but a title, especially after 64 years, is a title. I have not felt this warm kind of glow over sports since, well, January when I sat in stadiums in New Orleans and Dallas and just breathed in the joy and relief. But that doesn’t diminish the heartwarming end to a very long, very cold history for OSU wrestling.

In two weeks our thoughts will turn to Logan Stieber—the now four time B1G Champion and B1G most valuable wrestler—and his attempt to become the fourth wrestler in history to win four national titles. But for now I just want to relish what just happened. Here are some things I will never forget.

I have experienced many exciting times in St. John’s Arena—I have even competed in a few. But nothing matched the sheer excitement of Nathan Tomasello’s two dramatic wins. First he beat two time defending B1G and national champion Jesse Delgado (Illinois). Trailing late in the match he was able to hit a go ahead takedown and then was able to ride Delgado out for an excruciating minute. When he did, the crowd erupted in a way I am not sure has ever happened in Columbus in front of so many wrestling partisans. I thought the match would be an apt measuring stick for Nathan because I was sure he had grown to the point he was ready. And he was.

There was a little frustration with the refereeing, which did not surprise me—the same ref that squeezed a stall warning out of Nathan was the same one who, in the judgment of many, unfairly deprived Nick Heflin of an NCAA title last year. I mention this because that same referee came back to haunt the Buckeyes at several points, including Kyle Snyder’s narrow loss in the 197 title bout.

But back to Nathan. Last year, after completing his redshirt freshman year, he won the US Open Junior Freestyle title in Las Vegas. That entitled him to a bye into the final round for the US Team Trials later in the summer. Thomas Gilman, who had just competed as a freshman for Iowa, skipped the US Open but was able to grab an at large invite to the Team Trials where he upset Tomasello. The same result occurred when the two collided in Columbus for the Ohio State/Iowa dual. Tomasello had a score to settle and that he did, racing out to a three point lead, hanging on to a one point win after an escape and a stall.

An even bigger crowd erupted. As the first of three head to head matchups between the two team leaders—Ohio State and Iowa—the Buckeyes had to have this. When Nathan came to Ohio State he wanted to serve as a sparkplug to get the team fired up and he has done that. While Nathan is a thoughtful and respectful young man, he is a fiery competitor on the mat—just the kind of persona that can give a cue to those who follow. Now he has the hardware to drive home his message.

Saturday night (the second of three sessions) was a memorable one for the Buckeyes. The first session yielded few surprises—those Buckeyes expected to win did, those not expected to win did not. Which was disappointing. Immediately before the semis (where Tomasello enjoyed his sprint past Delgado), his teammates who had lost in session one sprinted through the second and third rounds of the consolation brackets. Two big wins each by Johnni Dijulius, Josh Demas and Mark Martin had brought the Buckeyes ever so close to team leading Iowa. By the time Tomasello, Logan Stieber, Bo Jordan and Kyle Snyder won their semi-final matches, the Buckeyes had made up a seventeen point deficit and now led the Championship by 1.5 points.

I also think of the maturity of Kyle Snyder. Obviously as a former World Junior Freestyle gold medalist, the young man must have some poise and that was on full display. Wrestling four seed Nathan Burak of Iowa in the semis, he was attempting to avenge his only B1G loss of the year. I will never forget how Kyle, after finally fighting for a one point lead with both wrestlers on their feet, planted himself on the end line. He knew all he had to do was not get taken down. By using the end line, he could force the action out of bounds if he got in trouble. Burak had no choice but to meet him there and take his defeat like a man.

I think of the fire of Johnni DiJulius and several astounding throws he pulled off, one to come from behind to score a late 7-3 win. I actually saw Johnni shoot twice rather than use his dreaded two on one looking for a dump. I have witnessed Johnni win most scrambles and I’ve rarely seen him lose one, so it has always occurred to me he should use this as a way to strengthen his already powerful tool box. He hit a great double leg in the third place match and after a long scramble seemed to have won the takedown. The ref disagreed but I loved the improvisation.

I cannot help but think of the guts and disappointment of Hunter Stieber. Out nearly the entire year with bad elbows, Hunter showed up for the Big Ten Championship and won his first two matches, looking comfortable and confident in the process. The second win however required a last second reversal after extended effort. The win prompted pandemonium from the crowd and sent Hunter automatically to the NCAA championships in two weeks.

But this is an elbow injury we are talking about—when hurt they always hurt and when Hunter came out for his semi-final match against Jason Tsirtsis, defending national champion from Northwestern, he simply offered his hand and with it the award of a medical default to Tsirtsis. At the time, Coach Ryan said Hunter would go in session three if the team needed him. It did, or so it appeared at the time. Hunter went out against a 16-12 sophomore from Illinois. Soon it was clear his left arm was limp. He hit one of his cobra strikes for a takedown but with only one arm could not reel in his catch. He quickly found himself on his back for the pin. Hunter’s sixth place finish delivered the points essential for the team title, but it came at a very high price. It is very likely he aggravated the elbow enough that Buckeye national title hopes will have to rest on his teammates.

I remember and credit wrestlers from other teams, who as enemies of our enemies became our best friends. First there was Tsirtsis who went to the 149 title match against number one seed Brandon Sorenson of Iowa. Although the Buckeyes had opened a gap by winning head to head title matches (Tomasello and Stieber), they had lost a third place match at 133. The Buckeyes needed help to slow the Hawkeye advance and Tsirtsis delivered with a one point win that went to the wire. He must have thought he was in Evanston as Ohio State fans urged him on and erupted at his victory.

Kyle Snyder lost a close match to coasting Morgan McIntosh of PSU (with the coddling aid of the suddenly oblivious to stalling referee that tormented Tomasello and Heflin). Meanwhile, on the mat next door, Minnesota’s Scott Schiller did the Buckeyes a solid by keeping Iowa’s Nathan Burak from gaining third place points.
With the team score tied at 120, and no Buckeye competing at heavy, the Buckeyes needed Northwestern’s Mike McMullan to stop Iowa’s Bobby Telford. It was a match-up of three and four seeds. Telford is the classic B1G heavy—tall, fairly lean, but carrying a bit of non-muscle extra weight for ballast. McMullan looked substantially undersized—shorter but without the unproductive weight. After Telford took a 3-0 lead, the drama seemed to have left the arena and the year but McMullan got an instantaneous escape, then used his quickness to spin around the lumbering Telford for a tying takedown. When he escaped in the third period, he played cat and mouse for the duration. The crowd counted an interminable 5-4-3-2-1 and erupted in delirium as witnesses to the crowning of hometown B1G champions.

Before I leave the subject of non-Buckeye wrestlers and the aid they gave, let me say one more thing about Thomas Gilman—I don’t recall ever seeing anything like it. On the award stand he hid his runner-up bracket card behind his back–i actually have seen that little pouty move often. But, then he bolted from the podium and ran out of the gym while Nathan Tomasello received his applause. The applause quickly turned to boos at the sight of Gilman’s “look at me” dash. I understand these are young men that in losses are dealing with a great deal of disappointment, but even twelve year olds know better than pull a stunt like that. It is true, Iowa wrestling is not known for its grace. But Gilman could have gone quietly to plot his revenge. What he did instead what essentially give an already intensely driven Tomasello bulletin board type material. That is not a smart thing to do.

As tempting as it might be to say the Buckeyes backed into the title after razor thin losses at 165 and 197, nothing could be further from the truth. In the finals, Ohio State won two of their four title matches—Iowa lost all four of theirs. In fact, Iowa won only one match on the mat in the last session when Cory Clark edged Johnni DiJulius for third. They did collect a medical forfeit (and the pin points that come with it) at 184. Of the two teams, it was an Ohio State wrestler who struck the last winning blow—Mark Martin.

In overtime for the fifth place match Mark hit a sudden double leg and muscled his way to the winning takedown. He beat his chest defiantly and with just cause. Mark had had bad luck throughout the tournament due to the seeding (which in reality he earned from his season performance). He faced Iowa’s tough Mike Evans in the quarters and lost a hard fought 2-0 decision. Then he ran into the ever tough four seed Logan Storley. Mark appeared to be riding Storley out for a signature win when Storley hit a freak move for the win. What Martin did do this weekend was show anger and toughness—two things that will help him in two weeks in St. Louis. He is good enough (sorry, did not mean to paraphrase Stuart Smalley)—you just sense if he could hit that break-through win he might go to a new level. He left the B1G giving you the feeling that might be coming.

As a footnote, as Martin was delivering the Buckeyes’ crucial last point, Storley was hanging on for a close win over Evans—another helping hand from up north.

I thought of Ammon Butcher, the phenomenal accounting student on a full ride scholarship from the Fisher School at OSU. As a high school wrestler he broke his neck in a tournament and now inspires everyone with his upbeat approach to life as a quadriplegic. Embraced by Coach Ryan and the wrestling team, he patrolled the sidelines this weekend and reveled in the same euphoria we all did.

And then there is Coach Ryan, the native of Long Island, New York who lost his NCAA championship match in what the famed Dan Gable called the most physically and emotionally exhausting match he ever coached. Coach Ryan finally landed at Ohio State and treated the program as a CEO would treat a business, investing his energies in all aspects of the program. An innovator and tireless worker he has recruited the most talented kids and built a fence around the talent rich Ohio high school program. Thinking of this passionate, friendly and funny man, I contemplated his joy even as he shared, or maybe in part because he shared, the honors with his teammate and long-time friend, Iowa coach Tom Brands. I thought of the smile that must be bringing to their common mentor Dan Gable.

And I thought of the powers behind the throne, assistants Ross Thatcher, J. Jaggers and the quiet genius Lou Rosselli. I watched them cajole, cheer and exalt in the progress, match by match.

This is the best ending Ohio State could have hoped for, overlooking if it is possible, the probable loss of Hunter Stieber (just my guess, as a long time sufferer of elbow injuries). The stars wrestled like stars and the potential All Americans wrestled like All Americans who now threaten to break through to elite levels. Josh Demas finished fourth only because he ran into the very strong James Green of Nebraska twice. He wrestled with passion and aggression. The exact same thing can be said of Johnni DiJulius and Mark Martin. The raw courage that Hunter Stieber showed was emotionally uplifting for everyone who saw it. The Jordan and Snyder losses are painful, but you just know they will come back looking for redemption in two weeks, because no doubt—they are the real deal.

Oh and then there’s that guy named Logan Stieber. My best memory of Logan this weekend was the poetic gesture of having his weight coach, the great J. Jaggers, a two time national champ himself, hand Logan his championship award on the podium.

Do the Wrestling Buckeyes Have the Right Stuff? Twuckeye with his take

After the Ohio State Wrestling Team lost to Lehigh—let me say that again, Lehigh!—it is tempting to say that the hype surrounding this team has exceeded its grasp. First, let’s be clear about something—in football, Lehigh is venerable (think Lehigh v. Lafayette) but insignificant on a national stage. On the wrestling stage however, Lehigh is more than a credible program—in fact it is a co-favorite to win the prestigious EWIA.

But come on—if the Buckeyes are the team we have hyped them to be—me most of all—then they should have been able to sneak by Lehigh. But Lehigh came out with an attitude that said, “you think you’re so tough? How about I hit you in the face a few times and then see how tough you are.”

Don’t get me wrong. Every young man who steps on a mat wearing an Ohio State singlet is a remarkable young man. They have each achieved a level of distinction in the world’s toughest sport that deserves our utmost respect and gratitude that they represent Ohio State. Recently I had the expectation of speaking to the team, which I thought was a weird joke of nature—it is they who can pass wisdom and experience to me, not the other way around. I mumbled through enough to have done my expected duty, but it was I who left feeling uplifted by our time together.

Nonetheless, when it comes to competition against their current peers, half the Buckeye lineup rarely disappoints, and the other half rarely surprises. We were hoping the narrative would change. Who wants to classify a remarkable group that way? But the truth is, to achieve its ultimate goal, the team has to have one or two wrestlers break through his collegiate past to become an elite competitor. At this point, while there are candidates to do so, none has shown many signs he is up to the task.

So, at the top are Nathan Tomasello, Logan Stieber, Hunter Stieber, Bo Jordan and Kyle Snyder. No one would be surprised to see any of them as a Big Ten champ or NCAA finalist.

The team is ably rounded out by Johnni DiJulius, Josh Demas, Mark Martin, Kenny Courts and Nick Tavanello. Despite my implication to the contrary, no one would be surprised to see any of these young men finish as All Americans—which puts them in the rarefied air of the top eight in their weight class. Each has either been firmly entrenched in, or has flirted at the edges of, a top ten ranking most of the year.

Yes, half the team could make it to the NCAA finals and the other half could be All Americans. If that happened the Buckeyes would in fact run away with the team title. The problem, in a recurrent theme, is math—not all those who could make it to the finals, and not all those who could be All Americans, will in fact do so. The odds say no.

If the Buckeyes are to achieve their potential, one or two in the All American tier are simply going to have to do what they have mostly failed to do all year—surprise in a pleasant way by wrestling above their ranking.

If that happens, it will be those individuals who will be the team MVPs because those will be the wrestlers who will elevate their teammates from being teammates of one or two NCAA champions to being NCAA champions themselves.

First, we have to recognize that although Hunter Stieber is an undeniable talent—he went undefeated until the 2013 NCAA semis, and still finished third—he has been out all year hurt. He intends to come back for the Big Ten. Of course Devin Carter of Virginia Tech missed most of last year but was still able to make it to the NCAA finals—only to get crushed by Hunter’s brother Logan. Still, it is a lot to ask for Hunter to duplicate the effort.

And of course, Johnni DiJulius could express great indignation at not being labeled an elite wrestler—he has beaten some very strong competitors in the last few years. But he also shows signs of fading as he did last year. In a sense, Johnni is as good as anyone in his class, but he is committed to a style that would make him unbeatable if he added more traditional wrestling tools. As it is, he is kind of like a pitcher with a great fastball without a second pitch. The good wrestlers seem to wait him out and go for a close win late. I would have preferred to see Johnni risk a bit this year and take the stride to diversify his arsenal, but it really seems a little late to do that now.

Josh Demas also has elite talent but he has had so much injury time away from the sport that he is chasing others who have been able to compete and advance over this period of time. Mark Martin, Kenny Courts and Nick Tavanello also compete well but the truth just might be that none of them has the right body type to compete at their weight. Having said that, Nick, who is clearly undersized as a heavy, wrestled like a mad man in last year’s heavy consolation bracket. He came one win shy of attaining All American status in an heroic series of matches. But he too has been hurt this year: even if recovered he has lost the experience and conditioning under pressure that he might need to make the same push down the stretch.

If there is a secret to a breakthrough, one may only have to look back as far as Lehigh. The underdog Mountain Hawks came in with a chip on their shoulder. Even though Nathan Tomasello won a major decision in the opening bout, it was obvious his Lehigh counterpart was fighting as hard as he could to force Nathan to give everything he had. At 164 Bo Jordan has literally beaten his opponents into obvious submission this year. While he put a tech fall on his Lehigh opponent, young Mr. Peppelman was fighting him off to the very end.

In other matches, it was just obvious that the Lehigh wrestlers were going to fight like a father defending his family. They pushed around the higher ranked Buckeyes and you could see the confidence grow with every match. At some point you expected to see an “I’ve had enough of this crap” explosion from the Buckeyes but it never happened.

In apparent exasperation at fans criticizing teammates, Logan tweeted earlier this season that people don’t understand how hard it is to win a match. Amen, to that—winning is brutally difficult and as I said, win or lose these warriors deserve our respect. But it is also the easiest thing in the world to lose a match you could have won. The Mountain Hawks put on display for everyone to see how a big dose of hostility can break the will of a better competitor.

What this team possess in talent, it frankly lacks in fierceness—in a sport where fierce goes a long way. Little Lehigh demonstrated what determination can do. Dan Gable once said a winning wrestler knows he is going to win before he steps on the mat. If there is to be a Buckeye MVP or two in an historic season, he or they may just need to borrow a page out of the playbook of a small eastern school and go out there with the determination to will his opponent into submission.

Welcome to March Matness: OSU Wrestling

wrestlingThat’s right. Ten years ago, a Buckeye crazed sports fan really only had football and basketball to occupy the rooting attention. Since then hockey and lacrosse have picked up a piece of the action and now, in the decade since Coach Tom Ryan’s arrival, Buckeye wrestling has assumed a prominent role among collegiate powers to produce excitement in the winter months culminating in the NCAA championships in mid-March.

Ryan. Tom Ryan.  Can his young Buckeyes stir things up?

Ryan. Tom Ryan

Wrestling is part alchemy for a coach because of the different weight classes and wrestlers of varying abilities and spectrums of development–and that is not even taking into account how a coach must stack a great team with an NCAA full funding limit of ten full scholarships. Trying to strategically place wrestlers by class and by year to maximize the potential of the team and individual is more art than science, but the various factors ended up in this being a “stretch” year for the Buckeyes as super talented wrestlers sat on the side line red-shirting while others filled in to get the team to stretch their potential as far as they can.

In those terms, this team, rather than packing it in, has kept the Buckeyes at their now customary top of the national pecking order. After some stunning early success, these young wrestlers settled in for the demanding test of the B1G dual meet season. The hopes certainly were to see growth of a cadre a key wrestlers with the goal of peaking into the B1G Tourney and the NCAA Championships. Now, on the eve of the NCAA Championships March 20-22 in Oklahoma City, we find ourselves with the suggestion the glass is either half full or half empty, but perhaps trending toward a pleasant surprise. You could break down the Buckeyes in several groups—those that have busted through to clear success, those who have seen strong positive progression with mixed results and those who can add points for team results but are likely not to bust through quite yet in their early careers. Let’s look at this week’s brackets in those terms.

Have Arrived

141: Two-time NCAA Champion redshirt junior Logan Stieber remains clearly on track to achieve the iconic status of being only the fourth wrestler in history to win four NCAA titles, despite moving up a weight class to 141. Stieber avenged his only loss in two years in the B1G Championship last week in Madison, WI with a pretty convincing 7-3 win over freshman sensation Zain Retherford of Penn State.

It seems a little odd that the seeding committee would then go on to seed Stieber second. The first seed went to Mitchell Port, a 2013 runner-up presumably because of his undefeated record, though he has yet to face Stieber or Retherford. It seems unfair to ask Stieber to face Retherford in the semi-finals and then get to Port in the finals.

But I’m not crying for Stieber. The guy I really feel sorry for is Retherford. He has wrestled at such an intensely high level it just seems unfair to have him go against Stieber in the semis. After watching the B1G finals and knowing Stieber has probably learned from that, as he always seems to do, and will likely open the gap even more, I don’t think there is much chance Retherford reaches the finals. The battle between him and Port would have been intense had Port been seeded second rather than Stieber. Either way, Logan officially becomes the most decorated wrestler in Buckeye history after he wins his third NCAA title this Saturday night.

U197: Senior Nick Heflin finished fifth last year at 174 with a dramatic cross face cradle pin of colorful Mike Evans of Iowa. This year Heflin has moved up to 197 and has achieved the perfect trajectory. After a confounding overtime loss to Wiscy freshman Timothy McCall, Heflin went on a tear, perfecting his offensive takedown skills and winning the B1G title. His 24-1 record earned him the only Ohio State one seed this year. Nick presumably would face former No. 1 ranked Scott Schiller of Minnesota in the semis, but Nick seems to have Schiller’s number. As I have said before, Nick seems to have the perfect blend of offense and defense now, and he looks simply unassailable on his feet. Heflin still lets matches stay too close, opening himself to a last minute mistake that could cost him a title, but I expect Nick to become OSU’s second title winner of the night.

Those Who Could Arrive

I lump four Buckeyes into the same category—guys who to my eye (admittedly–for what that is worth) are almost there. Their results in the months leading up to the NCAAs were mixed, but a closer looks suggests they are closing a gap and nothing would surprise me from any one of them. I would not bet on a national title this year from any of the four but I would not be shocked if a Cinderella emerged from this group.

125: Redshirt freshman Nick Roberts has been the hard luck kid. He shows brilliance from match to match and often within matches that bely his sixth place B1G finish. He wrestled B1G runner-up and 2103 NCAA runner-up Nico Megaludis extremely gamely in the B1G, letting the match drift away from him toward the end. Nick seems to be able to wrestle with anyone. Unseeded in the NCAA Roberts will be tested right away by fifth seed Dylan Peters of Northern Iowa. I would not be surprised to see Roberts pick off Peters, likely pitting Roberts against Tim Lambert of Nebraska. Lambert has pinned Roberts twice this year, but both were attributable to Roberts’ carelessness. Roberts started off dominating Lambert in their first match only to be caught off guard. In the B1G, the match was close until Roberts actually pinned himself in a rare defensive pin—clearly Roberts could have avoided that result with a little more care. This is not a case of Lambert owning Roberts—Nick just has to exercise more prudence. If Nick can bust through in those two he would face four seed Josh Martiniez of Air Force—another match I could see Nick winning.

That kind of success would be a cumulative surprise, but if Roberts can take the next big step and turn around close matches, he could find himself in the semis facing defending champ Jesse Delgado of Illinois.

133: Redshirt sophomore Johhni DiJulius is a guy who really showed early season brilliance only to stall a bit in the B1G dual season. To be fair, he was hampered a little by injury. Nonetheless he wrestled well in the B1G including a very close 5-3 loss to Minnesota’s David Thorn (see my earlier thoughts on DiJulius here). If DiJulius can also pick his game up a notch and overcome Thorn in a likely second NCAA match, he would then face No. 1 seed Joe Colon of Northern Iowa, a guy DiJulius beat handily at the Cliff Keen at the beginning of the year. Colon is likely not the same guy now, but perhaps this is a case of DiJulius simply matching up well with Colon. A win would put JD in a tough semi-final match against Tony Ramos of Iowa, but again the path is there for Johnni.

149: Redshirt senior Ian Paddock has suffered through agonizing injury almost the entire second half of what started as a very promising Buckeye career. This year has been no different. Paddock looks strong and he is in the best match condition he has enjoyed in a long time. But he still doesn’t look like himself—he has always been a forceful upper body wrestler, almost in a Greco Roman style, but he also had the ability to shoot for the legs—a trait noticeably missing at the B1G.

Still Ian wrestled well at the B1G losing 3-2 to Champion Jason Tsirtsis of Northwestern. He qualified for the NCAA as an at-large and is unseeded. Ian faces No. 11 seed Josh Kindig of Oklahoma State, a winnable match, and if he prevails he would likely face Jake Sueflohn of Nebraska. Sueflohn beat Ian handily a lifetime ago in mid-January but Ian has progressed markedly since then. Sueflohn has not let up either—earning the No. 1 B1G seed although he too was beaten by Tsirtsis in a close match.

This is Ian’s last go around. A true warrior every Buckeye can be proud of, if Ian is healthy and can conjure up his old magic, nothing is out of range for him. The beauty of sport is the chance to root for a guy like Ian Paddock. An even greater beauty would be seeing him bust through–he can wrestle with anyone in this stacked weight class.

184: Redshirt sophomore Kenny Courts is an amazingly gifted wrestler—you don’t see guys with quickness like his from his feet at any weight but especially up in the big boy weights. He can snatch an opponent’s ankle like no one’s business. Kenny probably needs another year to get stronger to compete in a very tough weight class but he is a guy who is capable of going a long way.

As a ten seed he should be able to advance to a second round match against a very tough seven seed Kevin Steinhaus of Minnesota. I think this is a very, very big hill to climb, but with Kenny’s talent I never rule anything out. The problem is if he does win he would run right into defending champion Ed Ruth. Somehow Ruth has actually lost this year, but he is just too dominant. If Kenny is to really be productive he will have to do it through the wrestle backs. While I thought Kenny sleep-walked through his B1G wrestle backs, in the NCAA All American status is on the line so I expect the motivation would be strong for a sophomore to continue wrestling hard. If Kenny’s heart is in his task he is a tough out for anyone.

The Cavalry—Those Who Can Add Valuable Team Points

If the Buckeyes do pick up two individual champions and get one or two strong runs from the Cinderella candidates, they could be in a surprisingly strong team position that could have them needing valuable team points from their remaining two wrestlers.

174: Redshirt sophomore Mark Martin is smart and talented but has been inexplicably inconsistent. As a 14 seed, I can see him winning a first match but running into three seed Robert Kokesh is just too tall an order. Mark will thus have to do his damage from early on in the wrestle backs—a task he is totally up to, and there is a big opportunity for him to do so. It might not be apparent to him in the early matches, but his ability to win from thereon could help the Buckeyes immensely. In a few years there is no ceiling on Martin—this year would be a fine time to get a jump on his future.

285: I just love heavy freshman Nick Tavanello. If you were disappointed by the Buckeye basketball team getting edged by Michigan, you can hold in your mind’s eye Nick’s thundering upset of B1G No. 1 seed Adam Coon of Michigan. Big Nick caught a last second double leg and then lifted and slammed the towering Coon to the mat for the winning margin. Nick has wrestled with hustle and skill all year.

Nick starts off with a pigtail match (kind of like a play-in for basketball fans) against a wrestler from Va. Tech whom he has already beaten. A win would pit him against the ten seed from Boise State. I can see Nick getting that far. Unfortunately he would likely face Connor Medbury from Wisconsin. Medbury seems to have Tavanello’s number so I do not expect much progression in the winner’s bracket, but there is no reason this steam engine cannot speed along in the wrestle backs.

Conclusion: This week will tell, but there is a lot of reason to be optimistic about where Coach Ryan’s team sits. A national championship expectation is realistically still a year away, but this could be a fun stepping stone. ESPN can let you see virtually all of the tournament. Stay tuned. I will be tweeting from OKC so follow me at @twuckeye and also check in with Coach Ryan, @buckeye158 and the OSU account, @wrestlingBucks. It should be fun.

MotSaG Reader’s Digest for July 14, 2013

b1g_iconBlog/site newsOSU LogoOSU FootballThe MotSaG Reader’s Digest is just that — a quick glance at the past week of content here at Men of the Scarlet and Gray. This will give you a chance to catch up on anything you may have missed during the course of the week. This isn’t everything we posted this week, so we always encourage everyone to subscribe to our feed, sign up for email alerts or simply check the website on a regular basis.

Site News

We kicked off the week with the announcement that we had added a host of new writers to site, most of which you have read in the past week or so and some you’ll read in the coming week. We have made a serious push to recruit some fine writers and I think we’ve been successful in that endeavor. We are excited to have such a good group.

Wrestling

Speaking of new writers, we also launched a new content category here on the site led by our new writer Garth: Wrestling. He spoke with future B1G member Rutger’s wrestling coach, Scott Goodale. Along with the future of the Rutger’s wrestling program, Garth also touched on the impact that Rutger’s is feeling in anticipation of joining the B1G:

Thus, at least for football, wrestling and many other sports, one suspects, the move to the Big Ten has to be seen as a recruiting bonanza

Garth also spoke with former Buckeye wrestler Reece Humphrey and his quest to compete at the highest level of wrestling in the 2016 Olympics.

Garth wrapped up the week with a personal story about Archie Griffin and his ill-timed sickness before one of the biggest wrestling matches of the future Heisman winner’s life.

Recruiting

Dylan gave us a recap of all the future Buckeye’s that were out in the Pacific Northwest the week before, participating in The Opening . The Buckeyes were well represented, bringing nine recruits to the festivities, the most from any single team.

Dylan says that Terry Mclaurin had the best showing of the nine Buckeyes there:

Terry’s numbers for the four events for Sparq were 4.4 seconds for the 40-yard dash and an amazing 44.8″ vertical jump. He also had a 42′ power toss and a 4.07 second shuttle run. In the final competition he came in second overall by winning 3 of the 4 events. In addition to his incredible athletic ability, on the last day of 7 on 7, he hauled in four TDs.

We also had interviews with David Dowell and Jonathan Hilliman.

On the basketball recruiting side, Chris K. gave us an update on Carlton Bragg, a target Thad Matta would love to land here in Columbus.

Football

Jeremiah (SYR) looked at the recently announced 2016 and 2017 football schedules. He also recapped the sad story of Ray Small and the sorry turns his life has taken ever since he left the Buckeye football team.

Coming up

We’ve got a lot of great content coming next week that we’ve been hard at work on and we are really excited about sharing.

We’ll be starting a new series looking at the Top 25 Football Players in the B1G, starting with #25 tomorrow. Here’s a spoiler: We’ll start with a Buckeye. Will we end with one, too?

We also will be introducing another writer that we’re really excited about, breaking down some of the technical aspects of the Tom Herman/Urban Meyer offense, starting with the tight ends.

That, and a whole lot more awaits as we lead up to the opening of camp in August

Reece Humphrey: A Buckeye Family on the World Stage

ReeceHump2

“Don’t judge me” defiant Parker Humphrey declares from his twitter account, @parkerhump14kg. At two years old, Parker may be thought by many to be too young to be an active tweeter, but defying convention has become a time honored Humphrey tradition. Indeed, with his healthily distended little belly he is right to contest the scorn of those who might disapprove of his dual fisted attack on two ice cream cones at once. The literal translation of Parker’s protest might in fact be a warning, “Dad, you do things your way, I’ll do mine my way!”ParkerHump

A fitting admonition indeed to a man wending his way through the madness of life at the top of the world’s most demanding sport, wrestling. The last vision of Reece Humphrey in competition was the backflip completion of an effortless double flip immediately after winning his second US National Title in Stillwater Oklahoma, in June 2013. In fact, little has been conventional about Humphrey’s journey to the top but no wrestler goes about his business with more genuine youthful exuberance than Buckeye Nation’s own Mr. Humphrey.

Parker’s granddad, Buckeye Jim Humphrey from Coshocton, Ohio, was himself a remarkably talented wrestler, having been a five time national freestyle champion, world silver medalist and Olympic alternate (unfortunately that was the 1980 Olympic team—which was denied the opportunity to compete in Moscow as part of President Carter’s boycott because of Soviet interference in Afghanistan).

Grandad Buckeye Jim Humprhey, From the '70s

Grandad Buckeye Jim Humprhey, From the ’70s

Although it would be natural to think Jim would have tutored Reece in wrestling from a very early age, Reece declares he had no inkling of his father’s success until after he took up wrestling himself. Reece got into wrestling in the sixth grade, which is quite late for a guy who has enjoyed the exalted view from where Reece has, and then only because his older brother Jordin stumbled into it. Reece recalls being at an instructional camp and seeing his dad show up to help teach and can be excused for thinking, as he did, “what the heck is he doing, he doesn’t know anything about wrestling.” Looking at Jim’s old photos from the early 70s Reece might have confused his dad with singers Jim Croce or Cat Stevens more than Dan Gable–busting out with “Time In a Bottle” must have seemed far more appropriate to Reece than his dad walking through the mechanics a high crotch takedown.

In some respects, Reece’s very success seems unconventional in the eyes of national writers and fans, who somehow incomprehensively seem almost surprised to find him at the top of a podium. The public mindset often establishes a peculiarized test of legitimacy that in wrestling is often based on NCAA titles—much like the basketball world tests its superstars on the basis of NBA titles won. Reece, like his father before him, had a great career at Ohio State but also like his father never won an NCAA title, though each acquitted himself with very high distinction. In 2009 Reece finished second at 133, losing a close 6-5 match to heated rival Franklin Gomez of Michigan State and in 2010, he finished third at 141 after having had the misfortune to meet freshman Kyle Dake in the semifinals as Dake was at the beginning of his historic run to four NCAA titles in four different weight classes.

So it was a surprise and indeed an upset to many when Reece defeated all comers, of any age, to become the 2011 national champion and world team representative (after placing fourth in the 2010 NCAA 141 pound weight class, Reece dropped to the 60 kilo weight class in 2011, which is 132 pounds). After his unfortunate loss in the 2012 Olympic trials, the temptation was to label the 2011 win an aberration. (In truth the only “fluke” was the bizarre match scoring and overtime rules then in existence which in the event of any tied two minute period, resorted to a purely random “ball drop” to start the ball drop winner in a superior position that resulted in a sudden victory “win” 90 percent of the time. Reece was twice victimized by that rule in a 2012 wrestle-off with former Oklahoma State Cowboy Coleman Scott who parlayed his two out of three period win against Reece into a face-off where he beat Shawn Bunch for the 60 kilo US Olympic spot. Disregarding the randomness of the ball drop the only person to actually win a period by conventional means in the Scott/Humphrey match—indeed the only person to score an actual point in the match—was Reece Humphrey). The 2013 win, now his second in three years, should now remove whatever doubts might have lingered as to Reece’s legitimacy as champion of the 60 kilo weight class.

But Reece Humphrey, now 26, is chasing an Olympic and world title and as such is again an underdog. His showings on the world stage have not been overpowering to date and he recently lost in disappointing fashion to his Iranian counterpart in the “Rumble on the Rails” at Grand Central Station in New York (also under the old rules). Nonetheless, a ninth place finish in Turkey (where the ball drop was yet again a factor in a quarterfinal loss to Didier Pais of France) in 2011 is no small achievement, and one could note that Scott, the 2012 Olympic qualifier who went on to finish second to Humphrey in the 2013 US Open, earned a bronze medal in 2012. A world title is well within Humphrey’s reach.

Reece believes his body is up to the challenge, which now must span three years if it is to culminate in a spot on the Olympic team in Brazil in 2016. He believes he has learned to train smarter and to avoid injury. And he believes he has gotten much better at managing his weight in a consistent manner that will leave him better prepared at match time. Indeed, for dietary and to some extent training matters, he borrows select pages from the all-out assault on life practiced by long-time friend and teammate JD Bergman. JD’s “diet”, which JD does not describe as such—instead calling it part of an overall change in lifestyle—eschews most grains, breads, sugars, processed foods and seeks out as much raw and organic food as possible—one goal being to burn body fat not merely sugar.

One also suspects that if he is to achieve success on a world stage, Reece will in fact continue along his own unconventional past. Reece Humphrey is a remarkably aware and thoughtful person. As an illuminating example, when asked what he might do after wrestling, he rotely goes through a laundry list that includes coaching, establishing a career sustaining wrestling club and sales positions within the sports and wrestling business. When specifically asked he admits to how much he would love to get involved in MMA fighting, but quickly dismisses it out of family objection. But the prospect that really lights him up is the intellectual tight rope world of high stakes professional poker!

So there is a familiar arc of success at work that has guided him from latecomer to twice national champion and seems at work again as he plots out his final three years in the arena, and perhaps beyond—the proven ability to out-think the rest of the world. “Yes, I had a successful wrestling father who is a big reason for my success—but that did not help me get started earlier and in fact I started very late, so to a big extent that was not an advantage, and beside lots of wrestlers have knowledgeable fathers who helped them along the way. And yes, I work hard, but really it is pretty difficult to outwork the best—we are all working very hard. What I have always done is to focus as much as I can on what I have done, what works and what has not worked, what works for someone else and how he can be attacked. The mental aspect of wrestling is how I have tried to differentiate myself and has been really what has helped me make up any gap I have ever felt.”

Wrestlers are commonly thought to be brutes, and the mere connotation of brutishness de-emphasizes the possibility that extreme mental acuity is required. But much like offensive linemen, the truth is that few endeavors require so much mental ability and quickness—and under extreme and violent circumstances. For every move there is a counter, for every counter there is a counter and at the highest level it is the mind that can think ahead and execute most crisply and decisively that prevails. Wrestling can be compared to trying to do a Rubic’s cube while being jostled in traffic—figure it out fast or get run over.

Any time he has faced a roadblock, Reece has fallen back on intensive study and devotion to understand what it takes at a very precise level to move past the roadblock. That formula has worked extremely well in the past and shows every sign that it continues to lead the way to success.
But Reece’s personal arc of success contains another critical constant. Reece had the fortune of having a mentor in his father who was wise enough to let Reece discover his own passion and gave Reece the space to figure out how to move that passion forward in a way that worked for Reece. While Reece may have come to wrestling late, he came to it honestly as it became his dream first, not his father’s. And then he had the benefit of a father who never pushed him to the point of burning out. Now, as an adult, his principal life relationship is with wife Meredith, also a Buckeye. If you ask Reece what is unique about him that you cannot read somewhere, he answers simply, “Meredith.”

Meredith Humphrey

Meredith Humphrey

This of course resembles a cliché, except that as you put it all together, you realize how truly significant and apt it is in the specific case of Reece Humphrey. Meredith, perhaps without intending to, seems to push buttons in the precisely same correct and supportive way as father Jim once did. Dreams of achievement are funny things—they can choke people and strain relationships and they can devastate people if not achieved. People handle them in different ways, achieve them in different ways, fail to achieve them in different ways and deal with the consequences of success or failure in different ways. Somehow the consistent theme of those principally involved in the intersection of their lives and Reece’s athletic chase has been how they have complemented him and nurtured him; how all involved have put those important yet personal and unpredictable dreams in context as still smaller than a life being lived and still smaller than a relationship among loved ones; and how all have still given honor to the dreams of just the one of them and given those dreams the necessary devotion or space as and when needed. It is an intricate and delicate equation that most don’t fully solve over time, especially given the youthful and fragile stage at which athletic dreams generally must be fulfilled. And because it is a process that does in fact arc over a good portion of life and responsibility gets shifted from person to person, like father to wife, it is a process that is so prone to breaking down.

So when Reece Humphrey says he owes everything right now to his wife, he is not speaking in cliché, but rather what he is saying, from the heart, is that father, son, wife and all have gotten through the most demanding transitions of this phase of a life with big and immensely hard dreams. As he was once in the hands of a wise and respectful mentor, he is now in the embrace of a wise and respectful partner, and as to their parts, father and wife have achieved a flawless passing of the baton. Of course dad is still involved—he was in Reece’s corner in the conclusive match in Stillwater, insisting on a video review for which Reece had no patience (he was still ahead and in typical youthful fashion, just wanted to get on with things) and the review resulted in a technical fall (win by seven points or more) to end the match right there in Reece’s favor. The point is, Meredith has taken over as life partner and dad has given up that role to remain as coach—an amazingly hard transition in the most average of circumstances and yet it has taken place successfully while witnessing the highest level of athletic achievement.

Go Bucks

Go Bucks

We can all be confident, that as the times arise, young Parker is not in fact judged but instead is and will be given the opportunity to choose his dreams and the support to fulfill them—because that is the unconventional Humphrey way.

The View from Rutgers: Conference Re-Alignment, UFC, Recruiting and Other Matters of Amateur Athletics

b1g_icon“The campus is alive—people can tell you much more about the 2014 football schedule than they can about the 2013 schedule” says Scott Goodale, coach of the Rutgers wrestling team. Starting fall, 2014, the Scarlet Knights will begin competition in the Big Ten which will then expand to 14 members with the addition of Rutgers and ACC charter member Maryland. For the record, in 2014, Rutgers football will receive visits from Michigan, Penn State and Wisconsin and will go on the road to play Ohio State, Nebraska and Maryland (by contrast, in 2013, the last season before Big Ten play, the Scarlett Knights play the likes of Arkansas, Houston, Louisville, Cincinnati,  Connecticut, Central Florida and South Florida).  The renewal of their long-time rivalry with Penn State has to be particularly exciting given that the two programs have not played since 1995—shortly after Penn State ceased being an independent power by joining the Big Ten.

While some treat this affiliation as a big yawn, one only has to dig a little deeper to appreciate why this could well be a move where the sum is much more significant than its parts.  I had a chance to sit down with Coach Goodale, who happened to be in my adopted home, Carlsbad, CA on a recruiting visit.  I was struck by how a wrestling program at a school like Rutgers now sits right in the middle of some of the big amateur sports and Olympic issues of our day.

Rutgers has certainly enjoyed football success, and much of it in the last decade, but few would pretend it has cracked into the level of consistently being an elite program, despite being a major football playing power in the talent rich Atlantic seaboard region.  While one always has to be careful about comparing football, which is species unto itself, to other athletics programs, in this instance Rutgers wrestling may be a useful comparator as it also sits in a talent rich region.

“The problem we have is that if a wrestler is interested in us, he is probably also interested and capable of getting into Princeton, Harvard, etc., so we often lose that wrestler. If he is capable of wrestling at a higher level, he often chooses the Big Ten, so we are somewhat caught in the middle.”  One suspects football is much the same—the Big East is typically not the recruiting draw that other conferences are for top tier talent, and while Rutgers may not have to compete with the Ivies for the next level of high school football talent, they still have to share that talent with a number of competing programs such as Boston College, West Virginia, Connecticut, Temple to name just a few.

Thus, at least for football, wrestling and many other sports, one suspects, the move to the Big Ten has to be seen as a recruiting bonanza, a point directly underscored by Coach Goodale.  There are some exceptions—while Rutgers may in fact be able to amp up the basketball excitement for moving to the Big Ten, the Big East was of course among the elite of basketball conferences (underscore “was” as the Catholic seven bolt from the rest of the old Big East—even retaining the name). Some sports might actually have a tougher go—men’s soccer for example where four current Big Ten teams do not sponsor a team (Nebraska, Iowa, Minnesota and Purdue).  Despite the overall prestige of the Big Ten, it might be tougher to recruit soccer players into a conference where less than all members are enthusiastic—one can only imagine how men’s lacrosse recruits in lacrosse-mad Maryland view the move to the much less lacrosse serious Big Ten (though the addition of powerhouse Johns Hopkins as a Big Ten lacrosse member does provide a powerful counter for that particular concern).

Obviously of course, the new money that will funnel through to Rutgers because of the move to the Big Ten will be felt across the board as the annual take, while uncertain at this point, will be millions more than it enjoyed before the move.  While football recruiting will not be affected at least in terms of scholarships, facilities will doubtlessly improve and recruiting in other sports will improve.  Wrestling was already fully funded in that the full NCAA allotment of 9.9 annual scholarships is provided at Rutgers—however, the dollar amount is based on in-state tuition, meaning it is quite a bit tougher to recruit out of state kids who typically have to pay a portion of tuition at out of state rates.  The increased budget as a result of joining the Big Ten is likely to allow filling those scholarships with out of state rates—a significant new bonus for the non-revenue sports.

Indeed, for 2014, the first recruiting year in which the jump to the Big Ten has had an effect as a recruiting tool, Rutgers has seen an impressive bump in the rankings of its commitments, highlighted so far by the overall number 60 ranked high school wrestler, Anthony Giraldo, ironically from nearby North Bergen NJ.  “Last year I would have been basically limited to driving around New Jersey looking for athletes. This year I am talking to you in Southern California as I recruit the best kids in the country—kids that know that by the time they arrive on campus they will have the chance to compete for a Big Ten title,”  says Coach Goodale.  With no disrespect whatsoever to the proud and successful Eastern Intercollegiate Wrestling Association, where Rutgers participates through the 2013-14 season, it is quite a step up to be able to tell recruits they will compete for their entire careers in the Big Ten—a conference that produced six of ten 2013 NCAA champions.

Football recruiting seems to be off to a similarly stalwart start.  College football recruiting rankings, inherently suspect, are even more specious when it comes to mid-year snapshots.  Nonetheless, after finishing 45th in the Yahoo/Rivals 2013 rankings, Rutgers football is up to 16th in the latest 2014 rankings (as of now, Maryland has not enjoyed a similar bump).

One also suspects this change in the state of Rutgers recruiting reflects an expanded travel budget in anticipation of Big Ten riches as much as it does the prospect of offering recruits the opportunity to wrestle in the dominant wrestling conference in the country once they arrive.

I was surprised to learn from Coach Goodale that the there is not a lot of buzz within the college wrestling community about the Ed O’Bannon case and its impact on collegiate sports.  It might be that wrestling is fighting too many other battles right now to worry about the speculative effect of what that case might bring.  Wrestling, which has been devastated perhaps as much as any sport because of Title IX, now worries about how the impact of a potential loss of wrestling in the Olympics might further erode its brand appeal with young athletes.  Since February when the Olympic executive board recommended dropping wrestling after the 2016 Olympics, many feel the battle being waged for permanent Olympic reinstatement September is being won.

It is ironic that one of the adjustments made by US and International wrestling to save wrestling in the Olympics has been to further embrace women’s wrestling.  One wonders, as Title IX continues to chip away at wrestling (for example, proponents were saddened to learn of Boston University’s recent decision to drop wrestling), could women’s wrestling not only help on the Olympic level but on the collegiate level as well? Wrestling is not a capital intensive sport—if a college can adopt a women’s program, the same facilities could of course support a men’s team.  And if the O’Bannon case does shrink the dollars available for non-revenue sports, could a sport like wrestling address Title IX and still restrain costs in a post-O’Bannon era? While women’s wrestling is still not on the shortlist yet of programs to be added by major universities, the list of smaller colleges adopting wrestling programs is impressive and growing.  Coach Goodale could not speculate on the future of women’s wrestling except to indicate there is a palpable buzz that did not exist in prior years and added: “if you watch women wrestlers at the highest level, it is really impressive how far they have come in just a few short years.  If this catches on, I could see women’s wrestling becoming a major force.”

Among the changes that wrestling adopted to save its Olympic cache was a revamp of bizarre and almost random scoring rules.  The most hated was a “ball drop” to decide a tie where one wrestler was awarded a starting position that led to a win nearly 90% of the time.  For the most part, fans and wrestlers have applauded the move to the new rules which penalize passivity and end a lopsided match more quickly.  Coach Goodale thought some of the new freestyle rules could have a beneficial effect at the collegiate level, especially the passivity rule which, if there has been no score for a set period, the referee declares one wrestler as the passive wrestler.  If no one scores in the next 30 seconds, the non-passive wrestler is awarded a point.  “I also like the one point awarded on a push out—make them wrestle in the middle.” Continuing, Coach Goodale adds, “and recently, someone suggested awarding three points for just the first takedown—that might make things more exciting too if a premium was put on early aggression.”

Despite potential challenges on the horizon for wrestling, in some respects the future of wrestling has never been brighter.  As the key building block for the immensely popular MMA/UFC, wrestling has an opportunity to reach a young, excited and huge audience–a genuine opportunity for mass appeal. Former Buckeye wrestling star Tommy Rowlands has been one of the most active persons in linking the popular consciousness of MMA to its wrestling roots.  Some of the most dominant fight names are and have been collegiate wrestlers, including Brock Lesnar, Randy Couture, Chuck Liddell, Chael Sonnen, Phil, “Mr. Wonderful” Davis and Buckeye strongman and pioneer Kevin Randleman.  Wrestlers watched former Hofstra star Chris Weidman rock the world by ending the seven year reign of former middleweight champion Anderson Silva.  The night was particularly sweet for the Rutgers wrestling community, Coach Goodale and his close friend,  volunteer Rutgers coach Frankie Edgar, former featherweight champ (currently ranked No. 3).  Edgar, one of the most popular UFC fighters of his era, shared the card with New Yorker Weidman and won an exciting and decisive bout against physically imposing up and coming Charles Oliveira.  Wrestlers now have exciting options beyond coaching—and the potential to earn enormous income.  “You see a great guy like Frankie Edgar, how much he means to the UFC and how much wrestling has meant to him.  He works out with our team as one of the guys–it is exciting to the kids, but you can tell Frankie gets a lot out of it too in terms of his own fight preparation.  I would never want to get hit in the face, but these guys come out of college, and they are so tough, and they have mastered the art of close contact and precise maneuvers.  For most of them, picking up boxing and cementing the other pieces is actually pretty easy given what they have already mastered, and before long, they are the ones dishing out the punishment. This fight game has gone way past boxing, and it is exciting that our young men are so much a part of it” observes Coach Goodale.  Then, siting back with eyes on the horizon, he added, “and hey, young women too. It’s an exciting new time, and I’m glad I’m a part of it.”

Indeed it is.  Welcome Scarlet Knights.